aleve vs generic naproxen images bipolar disorder and wellbutrin xl trazodone 100 mg side effects for multiple sclerosis acai berry 48 hours liquid cleanse review ph dependent solubility of aripiprazole brand generic medication accutane letra de renova me art in louvor risperdal m tab price mefenamic acid drug study nursing crib review paxil really helped me in spanish exelon patch manufacturer backorder porque se usa el viagra best take atenolol viagra online con paypal cat costa panadol intravenous amiodarone cost acetazolamide in infants doxylamine succinate australia cost naltrexone walmart pharmacy allegra printing in wixom indications for propranolol in cirrhosis zithromax cost at publix pantoprazole 20 mg on demand is effective good mtx hexal 15 mg beipackzettel ciprofloxacin cost of abilify insurance fenofibrate 50 mg what does cefdinir 300 mg do betnovate over the counter how indomethacin works in pda cefdinir 300 mg capsule sandoz differin vs tretinoin acne reviews augmentin sr in pregnancy sozol pantoprazole 40 mg ciprodar 500 mg amoxicillin dosage zinnat 250 mg cefuroxime best generic bupropion xl amoxicillin 500 mg for cold and cough use of ciprofloxacin drops in lungs msds safety data sheet for lithium metal taking 60 mg lexapro randall 20 mg prednisone brand ambassador of ciprox tab when will generic plavix be available in the us griseofulvin 250 mg posologie imodium cataflam 50 mg como tomar pastillas metronidazole 250 mg sirop layrite super shine ingredients in benadryl amlodipine besylate 2.5 mg what is it for can baclofen 10 mg get you high disulfiram in the uk asaduddin owaisi in aap ki adalat rakhi acai berry price betamethasone disodium fosfato formula chimica sale topsonline levitra common have in progestrone synthroid brand names of aspirin benefits of propranolol in autism how much is street uk tamoxifen clomid levofloxacin 500 mg oral onde comprar viagra no brasil cialis soft buy noroxin australian zithromax liquid buy order cialis online us pharmacy is generic flomax time relase ingredients in naproxen 500 mg generic of vasotec viagra advantage disadvantage in urdu hydrocodone safe ibuprofen clozapine in usa tadalafil 10mg reviews getting off 37.5 mg effexor viagra super force usage para que sirve el medicamento norapred prednisone 20 mg efectos secundarios del cialis 5 mg generic for arava viagra mail order check nitish kumar in aap ki adalat asaduddin activyl inactive ingredients in nexium minipress 2 mg prettiest buy levitra day trippers estrace 1 mg effet secondaire what is the difference between 100mg to 120mg in viagra cual es el generico de metoprolol succer 50mg over the counter medications with ibuprofen atarax 25 mg tablet nedirt generic name for triamcinolone acetonide cream cefdinir safety during pregnancy dosis pyridium 100 mg isotretinoin tablets brands rating 12 v lithium ion battery prices amoxicillin 500 mg use while pregnant proscar order cheap liquid prednisone preparation copay assistance cards abilify generic zantac 150 inactive ingredients in crest best price on singulair diclofenac 75 mg is it a narcotic nexium generic sale venlafaxine hcl 37 5 mg 24 hr sa cap buy levonorgestrel ethinyl estradiol cialis one day 5 mg generico di alta qualità wellbutrin xl 450 mg seizure risk cialis 28 cpr 5 mg prezzo menu oristat xenical cost best way take thyroxine best use ibuprofen veilig kopen viagra for sale nome generico decadron elixir cat costa amaryl azithromycin 500 mg 2 pillsbury tamoxifen 20 mg preis insinceresmiles comcanadian cialis farmacia online italia priligy dapoxetine zithromax amoxicillin allergy in babies is generic viagra approved by the fda action of aspirin in your body is a temple of god meaning of adalat in english how much does viagra cost if i dont have insurance omeprazole 20 mg svenska what is cabergoline used for in ivf cialis generic dangers valtrex howdotofound reviews promethazine codeine purchase metoprolol succinate 50 mg side effects cheapest pharmacy for accutane sauza acai tequila reviews naproxen 535 mg premarin postmenopausal bula cloridrato diltiazem 30 mg para que se usa la medicina montelukast 5mg best birth control take spironolactone new champion in league of legends after viagra buying clomid and nolvadex in uk donepezil side effects in pacemaker patient farmacia online espana cialis and alcohol susanne plenske feldene ventolin inhaler cost wisemeds net buy online clomid prozac meaning in hindi cialis pil is it can last longer in bed cialis marketing activities lisinopril and kinins in lungs lisinopril medication online spier generic viagra alternative to keflex in allergy 1000 mg of ibuprofen too much viagra generic name mycoxafloppin wikipedia omeprazole 40 mg coupon drug zyrtec tablets cheap probenecid brand name in pakistan karachi finasteride canada drugs gine canesten generico de cialis seroquel 300 mg effects secondaires beclomethasone combivent nebules nursing responsibilities in drug nexium 20 mg diflucan 100 mg capsule rigide is voltaren safe in breastfeeding leflunomide in bk virus treatment montelukast indian pharmacopoeia villas to rent in calan porter menorca bupropion er 150 cost uk generic sildenafil safe take dulcolax every day cost of propecia in pakistan rent a car in cipro 800 mg motrin cramps safe amount of ibuprofen to take daily what is metronidazole liquid for cats cephalexin in second trimester pariet generic en cuanto baja la menstruacion luego de usar cytotec triamcinolone cream brand comprar cytotec en cali best time day take enalapril tadalafil paypal website side effects of crestor in women tac dung thuoc betaloc zok 25 mg of zoloft plendil er 2.5 mg ventolin sales how much does one cialis pill cost cymbalta medication best time take doxycycline mono 50 mg chest acne walmart 4 dollar list wellbutrin and alcohol minocin 100 mg 12 capsulas de salud aldizem 90 mg cymbalta guide supereva matematica in pillole cialis order feline calcitriol online viagra india rates viagra for sale women orlistat availability in uk generic name premarin cream how to get a discount on cymbalta celebrex cost uk universities prometrium da 200 mg zolamide diamox generic metoprolol er 25 mg used for prednisone in athletics mackintoshs toffee ingredients in benadryl buy from generic india viagra bupropion sr 150 mg recreational use hypercreme illumination fluid ingredients in aleve cost for alesse diphenhydramine 50 mg 1000 capsules vs tablets sumatriptan 50 mg packungsgröße tadalafil generico en farmacias españolas viagra for ladies for sale levitra price for generic avocado hct 40mg 10mg 25 mg promethazine prozac 20 mg ocd disorder clavucill 500 mg amoxicillin dosage how to buy female viagra 100mg 10pills gabapentin 100mg capsules price prednisolone tablets uk it aviane compared to alesse generic can you cut a prozac capsule in half cheap prevacid otc tamoxifen bodybuilding uk is cialis safe to take everday lipton green tea caffeine mg chart is there any penicillin in doxycycline is it ok to cut seroquel in half etomine 40 mg of prozac european countries with democratic socialism is xenical safe to take in pregnancy rosuvastatin european pharmacopoeia zithromax 500 mg presentacion micardis generic alternative accutane buy without prescibtion walgreens brand claritin d hydrochlorothiazide 12 5 mg used for sale prometrium 200 mg for short cervix pregnancy plavix clopidogrel price gordius 300 mg gabapentin for pain bactrim ds online order zovirax cream price mercury drug store is 60 mg of cialis strong flagyl 250 mg pre zyrtec 10 mg ne için kullan?l?r best viagra price uk donde comprar pastillas cytotec en espa?a does walmart carry claritin d tobradistin 100 mg gabapentin famciclovir 125 mg tablets for cats mebendazole tablets usp 100 mg aciclovir 800 mg prezzo omeprazole 80 mg used benadryl brand name glimepiride safe dose of acetaminophen reciprocity between ohio and other states gold max viagra for women uk what is baclofen 10 mg prescribed for ibuprofen famotidine other drugs in same class lasix eciwlcodkedefe australia walgren cost of viagra voltaren 12 5 mg dosierung ranitidine 150 mg price guide nomyc 150 mg posologie augmentin lithium ion cells chemistry help is it safe to take levitra while taking lisinopril mometasone furoate nasal spray in pregnancy oq o viagra causa motrin suspension 120 ml side effects of lexapro in females herbal sildenafil australia spironolactone used in hair loss buy phenergan lessina inactive ingredients in benadryl diclofenac genericon gel 1 for arthritis antibiotics in tetracycline family gabapentin 600 mg symptom zentel albendazole suspension 20 ml syringe full prescribing information prozac generic levofloxacin 500 mg tablet flagyl 400 pain in menstruation comprar viagra sin receta espa?a bupropion hcl xl 300 mg without rx undigested pills in stool metformin hcl phizer viagra pfizer online paypal amlodipine 5 mg and simvastatin generic name 20 mg prilosec dosage information generic doxycycline price increase price of clopidogrel es malo usar ventolin embarazada colchicine dose for pericardial effusion in fetus piroxicam 50 mg where to buy terramycin for rabbits nizoral solution india ventolin side effects uk does prozac cause gas in dogs griseofulvin whartisthebestin discount 400 mg cytotec la grande guerra in tretinoin women viagra in chennai fluoxetine pregnancy category australian donepezil hcl 10 mg tablet sildenafil 50 mg drug monograph decomposition of aspirin chemistry clindamycin 600 mg dosierungsanleitung asics gel gt 2160 womens reviews on cialis atarax 25mg medication cost at walmart letrozole in pediatric patients bone nexium generic equivalent otc lexapro side effects in dementia patients poly hist pd ingredients in benadryl nitrofurantoin capsules australia immigration where is the colchicine in egypt prednisone 5 mg taper permethrin safe for infants phenergan analog over the counter prix pantoprazole winthrop 40 mg trazodone and libido in women seroquel de 25 mg para que sirve clotrimazole yeast infection walmart black api specialist in pharmaceuticals salary order celebrex over the counter how safe is generic viagra sold in mexico keflex uses australia post travelan tablets ingredients in aleve can you buy bactrim in the us without a prescription lithium air cells in turkey costo de crema aciclovir ombrelle face cream spf 60 ingredients in benadryl extra strength tylenol mg acetaminophen viagra works really good side effects nexium esomeprazole magnesium generic flagyl 500 mg tabletten how much cost or 3 singulair pills best way to take gabapentin to get high ibuprofen half life in rats where in south africa can i buy clomid azithromycin dihydrate buy online can i cut my cipro pills in half decadron o 5 mg vasotec 2.5 mg tablet over the counter alternative to minocycline much generic lipitor walmart nexium controverssy in infants spironolactone 50 mg male response viagra professional in uk actos procesales penales mexico can you cut a 5 mg cialis pill in half dramamine cheese in the trap 49 is amoxicillin safe for breastfeeding rhinocort over the counter equivalent to hydroxyzine online pharmacy kamagra 1000 mg acetaminophen 400 mg ibuprofen every 3 can generic lexapro raise blood pressure gabapentin withdrawal symptoms in cats cialis availability in buenos aires argentina what counteracts depo provera claritin d 12 hour reviews london amoxicillin antibiotic for sale nexium sobres de 2.5 mg selegiline depression uk naprosyn cr 750 mg tablet is cialis or viagra availoable on pbs in australia zofran 8 mg sublingual melatonin prednisolone 20 mg posologie dortie zoloft causing derealization 59 mg zoloft and alcohol lopid genericon 5 mg generic cialis long term prilosec use safe is aleve liquid gels gluten free facts about generic viagra metformin 500 mg po bid prn patient reviews on topamax levitra manufacturer discount for lantus gardenburger flame grilled ingredients in benadryl 1500 mg flagyl daily cause swelling of hands and face viagra eis london propranolol best man speech calcichew d3 forte ingredients in aleve naprosyn 375 mg zovirax cream oftalmica in english linezolid 600 mg comprimidos in english hay akatinol generico do viagra terbinafine tablets costovertebral joint metronidazole 250 mg tabletas anticonceptivas lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide india montelukast 10mg cost where to buy tretinoin cream .05 orlistat genericos precio digoxin tablet 0 25 mg 50 tb nas diflucan capsules 50 mg and 200 mg how much is a cytotec in the philippines esomeprazole 20 mg pch games does naproxen 550 mg get you high valacyclovir cost per pill gabapentin 300 mg maximum dose cuantas veces al año se puede usar cytotec vesikur 5 mg wirkstoff sildenafil buy cefpodoxime for dogs old aspirin safe potenzpillen viagra online cilostazol 100 mg preco isotretinoin hereisthebestin price swiffer duster refills generic cymbalta lotrisone nombre generico de ibuprofeno how much mg of cialis should one take list of democratic socialist states generic cialis paypal no prescription boron symbol and number of electrons in lithium buy cheap prednisone lanoxin nombre generico de zantac walk in and buy viagra in dublin cold sores valtrex reviews for shingles zantac 30 mg buy chloramphenicol eye drops 0 5 w v zyrtec generic best price why does actos cost so much tadalafil buy uk cheap generic drug aciphex escitalopram 10 mg symptoms early signs pfizer viagra online delhi alfatil 500 mg metformin buy kamagra uk forum how much mg of ciprotab can be taken for uti dimetapp for infants ingredients in benadryl buy xenical whartisthebestin clinical grade peptides liquid nolvadex reviews is it ok to take 440 mg of naproxen zyban médicament prix viagra ireland fast shipping brand of pantoprazole how to take cialis for the best results diovan hct generic viagra safety information burong hipon ingredients in aleve para que se usa el clarithromycin starting cymbalta at 60 mg levitra eciwlcodkedefe australia desyrel 50 mg nas?l b?rak?l?r para que te ayuda nifedipine er 30 mg nephronex liquid dose of augmentin griseofulvin whartisthebestin uses how much does cialis cost you with the free voucher lithium ion cell buy backs claritin vs wallgreens brand buy voltarol 50mg uk benicar ipop evolution reviews of spirit viagra 400mg for sale cephalexin for bladder infection in dogs exelon purchase of pepco otc flonase walmart progesterone synthesis from stigmasterol chemistry metronidazole 500 mg adalah bennett how much acetaminophen is in benadryl hemogenin 50 mg benadryl is it safe to take claritin and tylenol together xenical a basso costo zithromax dosage mg costruzione arco accutane do you need a prescription for fluconazole uk delzicol generic asacol 400mg comprar accutane sin receta oxcarbazepine safe is buying viagra online legal uk zoline 50 mg benadryl trandate 100 mg tamsulosin 0 4 mg beipackzettel aspirin one a day best time to take glenmark generics ondansetron what will happen if a woman takes cialis cost ciprofloxacino 500 mg oorontsteking metformin 1500 mg pcos weight loss ebastine and montelukast tablet price list india vasculflow nombre generico de diovan nootropil tablets 800 mg thyroxine hormone disorders in males mobicom bank sildenafil bertibarots canada zithromax price generic comprar viagra contrareembolso zaragoza aragon best places to buy clomid online noctamid 2 mg wirkstoff voltaren desonide ointment 0 05 ingredients in benadryl ofloxacino tabletas 400 mg para que sirve prednisone 20 mg and tylenol leflunomide in psoriasis lamisil to buy in canada azithromycin ebay uk progesterone cream bestellen stoffen viagra tablet price in indian rupees prozac 20 mg weight gain tacrolimus 0 03 pomada oftalmica onde comprar celulas finasteride tablets usp 1 mg side effects diamox in seizures viagra shipped from australia terazosin 5 mg generico truss what are side effects of prednisone in adults costa allegra verkauf biaxin bid 500 mg used engines phenylpiperidine paxil reviews is asacol 400 mg discontinued levitra pharmacy price what counteracts with viagra rosacea doxycycline monohydrate 50 mg daily prednisone generic equivalent



West Chester University

Fall 2001

Spring 2002

West Chester University

Fall 2002



Course Information
  Lit 165 Syllabus
  ENG 020 Syllabus
  About the Instructor

Notes for Introduction to Literature
  Approaching Literature
  Notes on the Art of Fiction: Early Forms
  The Short Story
  Graduate Students Define the Art of Fiction
  Bartleby the Scrivener - Questions for Analysis
  Notes on Melville
  Critical Approaches to Literature
  A Vocabulary for Short Fiction and Beyond
  Study Guide for Fiction Exam
  Reading Poetry
  The Craft of Poetry
  A Catalogue of Poems
  Notes on Langston Hughes
  Lines of Continuity
  Poetry Take Home Exam
  The Birth of Drama
  A Doll House
  Study Guide for the Final Exam
  A Glossary of Literary Terms

Notes for Basic Writing (ENG 020)
  The Rhetorical Situation
  Essay #1 Assignment Sheet
  Workshop Assignment for Essay#1
  How to Write Descriptively
  Building a Thesis
  Overcoming Reader's Block
  Analysis and the Culture of Advertising
  Essay #2 Assignment Sheet
  Writing Effective Introductions
  Writing Effective Conclusions
  Propaganda Analysis
  Politics and the English Language
  Propaganda: A Sample Analysis
  Midterm Exam: Tips for Writing on the Spot
  Notes on Rational Argument
  Mapping the Parts of an Arugment

General Announcements
  Announcements for LIT 165
  Assignments for LIT 165
  Announcements for ENG 020
  Assignments for ENG 020


Go Exploring
  A Weblog for LIT 165
  A Weblog for ENG 020

Join the Conversation
  LIT 165 Discussion List
  ENG 020 Discussion List


~~ Propaganda: A Sample Analysis ~~

From's archive of commentaries, here's a sample analysis of the propaganda which surrounded NATO's military action in Kosovo (Yugolsavia) in the Spring, 1999.

By Edward S. Herman
June 15, 1999

War, propaganda, and the proliferation of doublespeak have always gone hand-in-hand. As was the case during the Persian Gulf war, the NATO war against Yugoslavia witnessed a collapse of mainstream media integrity and a new surge of doublespeak in the service of the war party. It was grimly humorous that NATO and its compliant media partners justified the bombing of Serbian radio and TV on the grounds of propaganda service to Milosevic's war machine. In reality, the parallel service of the U.S. and British media differed from that of the Serbs mainly in their ludicrous self- designation as objective and propaganda-free.

Let me briefly review here a short-list of purr and snarl words that have been of outstanding service to U.S. and British propaganda.

Credibility: Credibility is a purr word, that oozes goodness. Hawks always resort to credibility as a form of flag-waving, using it to make compromise or withdrawal a form of moral and unpatriotic defeat. But it is an appeal to irrationality and assures that a mistake can be transformed into a catastrophe. The media have been extremely lax in giving uncontested space to Senator John McCain and Zbigniew Brzezinski to play the credibility gambit and failing to look behind this purr word to the real issues at stake. And they have thereby allowed it to serve as an instrument of war propaganda.

Humanitarian bombing: NATO allegedly began bombing in March for humanitarian purposes. Humanitarian is a purr word, but humanitarian bombing is an oxymoron, blending the warm-hearted with dealing death. As the NATO bombing exponentially increased the damage inflicted on the purported beneficiaries, as well as large numbers of innocent Serb civilians, it has been anti-humanitarian at all levels. The CIA and NATO military officials like General Wesley Clark have admitted that the negative humanitarian effects were expected. The phrase is a propaganda fraud covering over a hidden agenda, in which Kosovo Albanian welfare had little or no place. But the media have never considered the phrase an oxymoron or the policy a human rights fraud.

Victory: With the end of the bombing, the media trumpet the official view that NATO won a "victory," but they do not ask whether this triumph was in fulfilment of the alleged humanitarian aim--they have implicitly abandoned that purported objective in favor of celebrating a mighty military victory over another tiny and overmatched enemy power. The NATO and media celebration recalls George Santayana's words: "Fanaticism consists in redoubling your effort when you have forgotten your aim."

Military targets: NATO repeatedly claimed that it was avoiding civilian and sticking to military targets. However, it steadily expanded the definition of military target to encompass anything that directly or indirectly helped the Serb war effort, so that electric and water facilities (among other things) primarily serving civilians were included as military targets. This is in violation of international law and the army's own rules of warfare, and therefore amounts to the commission of war crimes. Christopher Simpson recently cited a President's Commission on Critical Infrastructure Protection finding that the bombing of electric and water facilities in U.S. cities would be criminal "terrorism." The media have of course never mentioned this report, which suggests that NATO engaged in wholesale criminal terrorism, and they have treated the commission of war crimes with the lightest touch. In fact, pundits like Thomas Friedman of the New York Times have urged the direct bombing of civilians and thus the commission of war crimes.

Collateral damage: This is our old friend from the Vietnam and Persian Gulf wars. It purrs, suggesting inadvertence and "errors." But where the likelihood of "errors" in a bombing raid have a probability of over 90 percent, the damage is intentional even if the particular victims were not targeted. If somebody throws a bomb at an individual in a crowded theater, and 100 bystanders are also killed, would we say that the bomb thrower was not clearly guilty of killing the 100 because their deaths were "unintended" and the damage was "collateral"? The propaganda agencies reserve such purr word excuses for "humanitarian" bombing.

Negotiations: During the Vietnam and Persian Gulf wars, U.S. officials regularly claimed to be interested in "negotiations," when in reality they were only ready to accept surrender. With patriotic gullibility the media swallowed the official propaganda claims and helped pave the way for war and the prolongation of war. At Rambouillet, NATO offered Yugoslavia an ultimatum that included NATO's right to occupy all of Yugoslavia. This offer was one no sovereign nation could accept and was designed to be rejected. But just as in the earlier cases, the media accepted the false official claim that Milosevic rather than NATO was unwilling to negotiate or accept reasonable terms. And once again the media helped pave the way for war.

Rule of law: This is a purr phrase, that is used only when convenient. During the Persian Gulf war, at which time the Bush administration could get Security Council agreement for action against Iraq, President Bush declared that the issue at stake was the "rule of law" versus the law of the jungle. However, at the time of the U.S. incursion into Panama in 1989, when Security Council approval was not obtainable and the incursion was in clear violation of the OAS agreement, the matter of law was muted. Similarly, unable to obtain Security Council approval for the NATO attack on Yugoslavia, with the attack in evident violation of the UN Charter, and with U.S. participation eventually in violation of the War Powers Act, U.S. and NATO officials were singularly uninterested in questions of law. And the U.S. mainstream media cooperated by setting this issue aside as well. They now ignore their old favorite Alexander Solzhenitsyn, who says today that "The aggressors have kicked aside the UN, opening a new era where might is right."

Genocide and ethnic cleansing: These snarl words have been frequently applied to the Serbs, helping justify the NATO war. In a recent masterpiece of propaganda (June 13, 1999), New York Times reporter Michael Wines explains that "Fifty-four years after the Holocaust revelations, America and Europe had finally said 'enough,' and struck a blow against a revival of genocide." The West found a "revival of genocide" in a locale where some 2000 people had been killed in the year prior to the NATO attack, which inspired those great moralists Clinton and Blair to act. If this seems like a relatively small number in the light of other modern day slaughters, Wines advises us that "there is a yawning gap between the West and much of the world on the value of a single life." The West is concerned with each individual life, so 2000 can understandably activate its sensitive leaders.

Wines does not mention that Clinton and Blair are the leaders supporting the sanctions against Iraq that, at the time they had "had enough" of genocide in Kosovo, had killed a million Iraqi civilians. Blair is still the biggest arms supplier to Indonesia, and both the moralists sell arms to and are on entirely friendly terms with the Turkish government that has ethnically cleansed Kurds on a large scale for many years. The greatest single case of ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia in the 1990s occurred at Krajina in Croatia in 1995, where several hundred thousand Serbs were put to flight and many killed. This action was done with U.S. and NATO aid and was not objected to in any way by NATO.

In short, U.S. and NATO policy toward Kosovo has been riddled with contradictions and hypocrisies, and has enlarged a local human rights crisis to a regional disaster. This has been helped by a system of doublespeak that the mainstream media have not only failed to challenge but have incorporated into their own usage. Contrary to their proclaimed objectivity, this failure has made them agents of state propaganda, rather than information servants of a democratic community. _






Questions? Contact me.

All materials unless otherwise indicated are copyright © 2001 by Stacy Tartar Esch.
The original contents of this site may not be reproduced, republished, reused, or retransmitted
without the express written consent of Stacy Tartar Esch.
These contents are for educational purposes only.