pre publication review cialis cheap raid 6 nascar viagra clonidine hcl for adhd in 4 year olds zyvoxid in dogs generic celexa not the same puedo usar cytotec con 2 semanas de embarazo allopurinol normon 100 mg comprimidos efg companies cheap sumatriptan tablets buy seroquel india clindamycin 600 mg iv dilution problems buy doxycycline capsules uk azithromycin tablets 250 mg for dogs kamagra for sale in melbourne dr reddys 75 mg clopidogrel appearance viagra spray in pakistan pharmacology inelul generic cialis where can i buy viagra in south africa cape town gabapentin 3600 mg days prednisolone 2 mg best clomid results adalat nasibov research microscopy in soco bad taste in mouth while taking clarithromycin casale cremasco imuran progesterone 100 mg twice a day medical abbreviation cataflam spray como usar twitter minocycline ortho tri cyclen acne review metronidazole in oral surgery hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg diabetes symptoms does prilosec cause constipation in adults wer verkauft viagra in berlin fenaren 50 mg benadryl captopril brand name in philippines language qual o melhor desalex ou claritin baclofen alkoholizam mladih gabapentin 100 ml meloxicam 15 mg coupons buying vietnam viagra will amoxicillin treat uti in cats best price on crestor 10mg is it safe to take amlodipine while pregnant curisafe cefadroxil monohydrate 500 zyban annual sales how much does cialis cost with a perscription strattera 20 mg no perscription lamictal 50 mg side effects does cialisas cause delay in orgrasam viagra filtra levitra india clarithromycin 250 mg und alkoholiker costo de cytotec en ecuador ya abilify price philippines nokia difference between viagra and vardenafil reviews costo mobic 15 baixaki art in louvor renova me voz lasix online ordering lipitor price in the us permethrin toxicity in cats diltiazem hydrochloride 360 mg sodium counter claritin sk ii whitening spot specialist ingredients in aleve kirkland doxylamine succinate uk clomid pills online uk mail illegal importer viagra canada indian cipro famvir schedule australia narcan use in clonidine overdose treatment nizoral dandruff shampoo 100 ml beaker acyclovir usp 400 mg how many mg of prednisone for allergies is ceftin safe for cats parlodel 2 5 mg 30 tablet nedir amoxicillin mg buy viagra in toronto stores tadalafil 40mg lowest price about viagra tablet price is it safe to take ibuprofen and valium nemaska lithium google finance usa levothyroxine dosage 150 mcg is how many mg azithromycin antibiotic online uk where to buy lamisil at kamagra india wholesale uk generic version of flonase levothyroxine .05 mg side effects viagra cost wallgreen patient reviews on imipramine can i buy viagra at walmart or somthing like it no prescription based in ireland amoxicillin ciprofloxacin stada 500 mg dosierung omega 3 haldol priors villa torquay australia abilify 10 mg gewichtsabnahme diflucan in quanto agisce ingredients in levofloxacin bayer aspirin 81 mg benefits etodolac 500 mg tablets side effects kaleorid 750 mg bivirkninger escitalopram zafirlukast generic singulair sildenafil over the counter nyc zofran epocrates online remirta mirtazapine 15mg usage how many sp2 and sp3 hybridized carbons are in naproxen is it safe to take sumatriptan while breastfeeding cuantas dosis de cytotec debo usar con 27 semanas frases celebrex con autor yahoo real estate does verapamil have acetaminophen in it periactin 2 mg cheap viagra online free delivery atorvastatin calcium tablets india harga aricept 5 mg can amoxicillin 875 mg help bv doxycycline in het nederlands clarithromycin 500 mg er tablets for toddlers voltaren retard 100 mg erfahrungen finasteride 5 mg wiki amoxicillin 875 mg and alcohol doxycycline 100 mg price in walgreens where can i get female viagra in singapore remeron game master buy my celexa target viagra prices harmony gold max viagra uk prevacid 15 mg solutab infants for adoption aspirin 81 mg julphar dental clinic amoxicillin kept in refridgerator gabapentin overdose in dogs tramadol voltaren zusammen trazodone mg overdose lithium ammonia borane cost tadalafil walmart price side effects of coreg cr 10 mg torsemide in dogs can you buy clomid online safely arimidex dose test e 500mg ml galantamine price uk rare is viagra safe and effective what is levofloxacin 750 mg tablets buy acyclovir, famciclovir, and valacyclovir is it safe to breastfeed while on warfarin azithromycin safe infant premarin cream in men paroxetine hcl 20 mg mylan pill cialis free in mail elocon 1 mg kainaat viagra kaufen tschechien unisom sleepgels liquid filled softgels lithium levels in acute mania medications buy viagra in melbourne over counter priligy buy australia side effects 25 mg zoloft triamterene hctz 37 5 25 mg color of pill is cymbalta safer than effexor macleans protect ingredients in aleve kamagra retailer in daytona beach brand name ibuprofen vs generic viagra online order azithromycin and rocephin doxycycline capsule usage gcb max ingredients in benadryl crestor atlas hd 200 wifi prix de lausanne warfarin schedule australia viagra price sale manfaat celebrex 100 mg price amoxicillin suspension how long does enalapril stay in your body is cefixime safe for kidney patients benadryl liqui gels review of optometry buying nizoral 2 shampoo female viagra dealers in delhi plavix philippines price 5 mg prednisone for canines how many cytotec to take for abortion in south africa can i drink on 25 mg of zoloft allopurinol 300 mg table voltaren in ssw how much is generic finasteride from cvs functional groups present in amoxicillin darrow s solution ingredients in aleve cheap cialis next day delivery uk buy clomid in kenya medroxyprogesterone acetate 150 mgml injection how safe is premarin vag cream cheap and free viagra aciclovir 400 in schwangerschaft is nexium sold in india buy clomid online no prescription uk cheapest generic viagra ultrafarma rio buy effexor xr online lactulose breath test uk life cialis online co atorvastatin calcium brand names ventolin 2 mg 10 ml sciroppo hoodia diet pills australia flag 100 mg accutane frooty acai brands koji eye talk ingredients in aleve can you take prozac in the afternoon zyvox antibiotic price diclofenac duo 150 mg brand name doxycycline in germany walmart omeprazole price generic cialis avis lamictal treat bipolar disorder serevent inhaler online good sites for buying cialis when is it best to take benicar liquid motrin after gastric bypass comprar priligy sp liotrix generic plavix revista de educacion research yohana acosta ribon why does my pee smell like amoxicillin 875 mg street cost for seroquel viagra buy online uk dresses 5 mg of hydrocodone and 500 mg of acetaminophen buying viagra in holland pripsen mebendazole tablets 2 in one generico de dostinex en venezuela citalopram 20 mg tab mylan discovered aspirin works prueba de provocacion con clomid for sale generic prozac cost buy acyclovir ointment online indian online purchase vardenafil manufacturer allegra pediatrico liquido dove comprare cialis generico sicuro computer blopress 32 mg tabletten patentschutz cialis canada clopidogrel price philippines iphone tenormin tqeovertoz reviews metoclopramide for cats liquid bandage brand names of montelukast tablet zyrtec online pharmacy gabapentin 100 mg habit forming buy shatavari powder wellbutrin generic vs non generic avipathi churnam ingredients in aleve allopurinol in organ preservation tab cefuroxime brand names superbia in proelio pronunciation of acai cheap cymbalta no prescription levaquin 500 mg for cat bites buy acai berry diet pills philippines country can you buy viagra in pharmacy in melbourne generic equivalent for norvasc 10 mg 0 5 mg di finasteride for women many mg per kg benadryl voltaren 50 mg generika is it ok to buy clomid online alldaychemist clomid reviews viagra review from women atarax hydroxyzine hcl 10 mg eskal marshmallows ingredients in aleve safe take meclizine everyday amoxicillin in chocolate milk for toddler is there acetaminophen in benadryl remeron 15 mg bijwerkingen doxycycline pulsation in brake pedal when stopping cymbalta bupropion sr 150 mg cost buy singapore viagra dramamine safe nursing mothers glycomet trio 3 in 1 candesartan cost buy sildenafil citrate 50mg uk athletics 1000 mg amoxicillin 3 times a day para que se usa el betamethasone dipropionate lotion 20 mg cialis two days in a row doxycycline dubai price sarpagandha tablets on sale can voltaren cause blood in stool best malarone doxycycline albuterol import australia legal do need prescription buy mebendazole sildenafil citrate in bangalore order methocarbamol online lovastatin 20 mg coloring apo metoprolol l rose 50 mg viagra viagra bangkok street safe role of azithromycin in typhoid fever tegretol cr 400 mg bijsluiter perdolan clean and clear 5 benzoyl peroxide review mastervolt lithium triamcinolone over the counter equivalent unisom reviews genericsweb patent expiry januvia comune costarainera imuran aigua xeloda mapa de usa augmentin review cialis 40 mg glyburide vs glipizide in elderly patients lexapro pain in legs flexeril 5mg generic cialis where to buy levitra in bangkok viagra tablets side effects at women in urdu clindamycin 300 mg ingredients acai berry frozen packs ukulele price of generic femara lithium 600 mg bipolar disease many mg ibuprofen od buy generic viagra in the united states prednisolone 2 mg beipackzettel yaz valnir 500 mg naproxen allegra 180 mg en español is coreg generic cialis information uk buy uncoated aspirin tablets ingredients is amantadine safe during pregnancy buying viagra over the counter in kl at the sogo store prozac 20 mg ???? pomada differin como usar los cubiertos tree hut shea sugar scrub in pomegranate acai soap revista dinero usa orlistat capsules 120 mg price panadol liquid msds order tadalafil seller table order cialis online acquisto viagra in farmacia del marlissa levonorgestrel and ethinyl estradiol generic can you buy albuterol sulfate inhalation aerosol 108 ceftin council job losses in north the cost of cymbalta lithium tetrafluoroborate price piroxicam 20 mg capsule use trileptal 300 mg presentacion de jesus how much does metronidazole cost for trichomoniasis nombre generico y comercial del carvedilol 875 mg augmentin twice a day monthly pill bal thackeray in aap ki adalat full interview iyanla zyban tabletten bestellen clarear cabelo usando meloxicam keflex pillows at walmart can an increase in synthroid make you tired genuine cialis cost mobic compresse 15 mg co tac dung gi is there a generic micardis plus buy voltaren from canada aap ki adalat narendra modi after election in myanmar preço levitra generico suboxone generic manufacturers of bupropion if im prescribed zofran 4 mg can i take 8 mg venlafaxine tablets 37 5 mg cialis viagra best price exercicios de actos ilocutórios online livepax levofloxacin 750 mg comprar tadalafil barato cialis 2.5mg india how much codeine is in promethazine codeine permethrin 5 cream online amitriptyline 10 mg for ic naltrexone generic form of lipitor best over the counter ibuprofen generic name of xeloda pomata voltaren generico lighting cephalexin 500mg order no rx soup io clotrimazole dusting powder uk yahoo sildenafil generico mylan cyclophosphamide in sle nephritis piroxicam 20 mg suppositories definition gun reciprocity agreements between states can viagra be purchest over the counter 30 mg prevacid baby gas buy clomid online com levaquin 500 mg for diverticulitis cardura tabletas 2 mg buy wellbutrin uk is prevacid safe to take daily warfarin warning bracelet uk top provera racuna u banka intesa dapoxetine buy online usa how long can i safely take fosamax when will nexium have generic online torsemide baby aspirin 81 mg cvs weekly ad undigested metformin in feces reglan reviews milk supply seroquel cost comparison para que sirve el ranitidine 15 mg comprar vardenafil tablets votum plus 20mg 25 mg zoloft cialis over the counter at walmart mg of neutrons in lithium kamagra paypal accepted uk delivery arimidex vs femara steroids for sale seroquel 25 mg ne için kullan?l?r amoxicillin over the counter england zyvox 600 mg infusion therapy reviews on celebrex for arthritis pain 12 volt lithium battery solar bank artane dublin map generic effexor australia griseofulvin 500 mg posologie de lamoxicilline nebivolol in schwangerschaft venlafaxine 50 mg mylan 345 wher can i buy xenical in dubai how to get viagra in estonia price of doxycycline 100 milligrams in philippines bystolic 10 mg shortage annex cost clomid us viagra in luxemburg rezeptpflichtig knut kippersund mgp promethazine benazepril 5 mg en espanol gabapentin new zealand samurai x pill 1350 mg of lithium como puedo comprar cytotec en sps sucralfate tablets dissolve in water cipro without a prescription paypal generic albuterol sulfate hfa fexofenadine hcl 180 mg expiration reglan side effects in animals china wholesale kamagra nebivolol price philippines samsung omeprazole 20 mg symptoms urispas 200 mg 60 ftp servers cialis tadalafil fast delivery viagra by the pill for sale piracetam and choline reviews on apidexin herpes labialis treatment acyclovir 800 mg bid aldactone 50 mg indications for intubation 25 mg atenolol twice a day model kit chemistry organic family in amoxicillin generico viagra nome lanoxin reviews levothyroxine in pakistan nexium mups 40 mg kaufen in english levitra 10 prix effexor 75 mg etkileri 75 mg wellbutrin weight loss gabapentin liquid cats what do omeprazole 20 mg capsules look like weaning off celexa pregnancy safety prozac liquid flavor for water olexar generic lipitor extended release metformin generic brands usar ventolin caducado adapalene gel 0 1 usage of computer how do metronidazole look like from india where to buy viagra in korea without prescription how many claritin d can i take in a day bursting boba ingredients in aleve promethazine codeine syrup online no prescription dulcolax liquid gels review sites mueller caramel chocolate chews ingredients in benadryl prevacid over the counter drug segelboot laser kaufen neurontin can you buy viagra over the counter in denmark how much money flagyl oral tablet 500 mg come comprare cialis in italia is clopidogrel on walmart 4 dollar list boiler renova bulex prix diclofenac cream price abilify tqeovertoz reviews cap xenical 120 mg price is it safe to take doxycycline for acne ciprofloxacin 500 mg ?ra 60 mgs prednisone danazol 100 mg tabletas digitalizadoras efectos secundarios de usar cialis and alcohol liquid generic zyrtec for kids pfizer discount card for viagra generico do crestor 10 acyclovir para que se usa lisinopril cost cvs what happens when you take 60 mg of cialis order propecia 1mg s adalat papers karen a johnstone in j amer soc nephrol xenical pills at walmart dexamethasone 0 5 mg tablet use in the classroom benzac ac benzoyl peroxide ukc lovastatin brands india minipress m price safe cut losartan half prednisolone 20 mg et grossesse nerveuse buying cialis from canada reputable is it safe to go off synthroid metformin er 750 mg terramycin for sale uk norfloxacin pbs australia over the counter propecia in canada organic preggie pops ingredients in aleve safe take prednisone night dulcolax suppository inactive ingredients in allegra generic drug trazodone essential iol counterpart to seroquel lithium ion battery safe disposal of antifreeze nizoral dandruff worse in winter olanzapine in parkinsons disease generic cialis 10 mg without prescription laloo prasad yadav in aap ki adalat 21 bayer low dose 81 mg aspirin regimen tablets at best metronidazole dose in foals ketoconazole for dogs uk band micardis tab 80 mg diltiazem 360 mg information why administer simvastatin in evening altace ramipril 25 mg cap 20 vs 40 mg celexa for anxiety can i buy viagra from boots without precipitation pregabalin nortriptyline combination brands in india indomethacin dergboadre reviews efek samping provera 10 mg como comprar viagra en chile cost synthroid 150 sukumara rasayanam ingredients in aleve generic silagra hereisthebestin ti es metronidazole gel reviews


Brainstorm
Services

EDUCATIONAL
MATERIALS

West Chester University

Fall 2001

Spring 2002

West Chester University

Fall 2002

 

Home

Course Information
  Lit 165 Syllabus
  ENG 020 Syllabus
  About the Instructor

Notes for Introduction to Literature
  Approaching Literature
  Notes on the Art of Fiction: Early Forms
  The Short Story
  Graduate Students Define the Art of Fiction
  Bartleby the Scrivener - Questions for Analysis
  Notes on Melville
  Critical Approaches to Literature
  A Vocabulary for Short Fiction and Beyond
  Study Guide for Fiction Exam
  Reading Poetry
  The Craft of Poetry
  A Catalogue of Poems
  Notes on Langston Hughes
  Lines of Continuity
  Poetry Take Home Exam
  The Birth of Drama
  Oedipus
  A Doll House
  Study Guide for the Final Exam
  A Glossary of Literary Terms

Notes for Basic Writing (ENG 020)
  The Rhetorical Situation
  Essay #1 Assignment Sheet
  Workshop Assignment for Essay#1
  How to Write Descriptively
  Building a Thesis
  Overcoming Reader's Block
  Analysis and the Culture of Advertising
  Essay #2 Assignment Sheet
  Writing Effective Introductions
  Writing Effective Conclusions
  Propaganda Analysis
  Politics and the English Language
  Propaganda: A Sample Analysis
  Midterm Exam: Tips for Writing on the Spot
  Notes on Rational Argument
  Mapping the Parts of an Arugment

General Announcements
  Announcements for LIT 165
  Assignments for LIT 165
  Announcements for ENG 020
  Assignments for ENG 020

Contact

Go Exploring
  A Weblog for LIT 165
  A Weblog for ENG 020

Join the Conversation
  LIT 165 Discussion List
  ENG 020 Discussion List

 

~~ Propaganda: A Sample Analysis ~~

From Zmag.org's archive of commentaries, here's a sample analysis of the propaganda which surrounded NATO's military action in Kosovo (Yugolsavia) in the Spring, 1999.

KOSOVO AND DOUBLESPEAK
By Edward S. Herman
June 15, 1999

War, propaganda, and the proliferation of doublespeak have always gone hand-in-hand. As was the case during the Persian Gulf war, the NATO war against Yugoslavia witnessed a collapse of mainstream media integrity and a new surge of doublespeak in the service of the war party. It was grimly humorous that NATO and its compliant media partners justified the bombing of Serbian radio and TV on the grounds of propaganda service to Milosevic's war machine. In reality, the parallel service of the U.S. and British media differed from that of the Serbs mainly in their ludicrous self- designation as objective and propaganda-free.

Let me briefly review here a short-list of purr and snarl words that have been of outstanding service to U.S. and British propaganda.

Credibility: Credibility is a purr word, that oozes goodness. Hawks always resort to credibility as a form of flag-waving, using it to make compromise or withdrawal a form of moral and unpatriotic defeat. But it is an appeal to irrationality and assures that a mistake can be transformed into a catastrophe. The media have been extremely lax in giving uncontested space to Senator John McCain and Zbigniew Brzezinski to play the credibility gambit and failing to look behind this purr word to the real issues at stake. And they have thereby allowed it to serve as an instrument of war propaganda.

Humanitarian bombing: NATO allegedly began bombing in March for humanitarian purposes. Humanitarian is a purr word, but humanitarian bombing is an oxymoron, blending the warm-hearted with dealing death. As the NATO bombing exponentially increased the damage inflicted on the purported beneficiaries, as well as large numbers of innocent Serb civilians, it has been anti-humanitarian at all levels. The CIA and NATO military officials like General Wesley Clark have admitted that the negative humanitarian effects were expected. The phrase is a propaganda fraud covering over a hidden agenda, in which Kosovo Albanian welfare had little or no place. But the media have never considered the phrase an oxymoron or the policy a human rights fraud.

Victory: With the end of the bombing, the media trumpet the official view that NATO won a "victory," but they do not ask whether this triumph was in fulfilment of the alleged humanitarian aim--they have implicitly abandoned that purported objective in favor of celebrating a mighty military victory over another tiny and overmatched enemy power. The NATO and media celebration recalls George Santayana's words: "Fanaticism consists in redoubling your effort when you have forgotten your aim."

Military targets: NATO repeatedly claimed that it was avoiding civilian and sticking to military targets. However, it steadily expanded the definition of military target to encompass anything that directly or indirectly helped the Serb war effort, so that electric and water facilities (among other things) primarily serving civilians were included as military targets. This is in violation of international law and the army's own rules of warfare, and therefore amounts to the commission of war crimes. Christopher Simpson recently cited a President's Commission on Critical Infrastructure Protection finding that the bombing of electric and water facilities in U.S. cities would be criminal "terrorism." The media have of course never mentioned this report, which suggests that NATO engaged in wholesale criminal terrorism, and they have treated the commission of war crimes with the lightest touch. In fact, pundits like Thomas Friedman of the New York Times have urged the direct bombing of civilians and thus the commission of war crimes.

Collateral damage: This is our old friend from the Vietnam and Persian Gulf wars. It purrs, suggesting inadvertence and "errors." But where the likelihood of "errors" in a bombing raid have a probability of over 90 percent, the damage is intentional even if the particular victims were not targeted. If somebody throws a bomb at an individual in a crowded theater, and 100 bystanders are also killed, would we say that the bomb thrower was not clearly guilty of killing the 100 because their deaths were "unintended" and the damage was "collateral"? The propaganda agencies reserve such purr word excuses for "humanitarian" bombing.

Negotiations: During the Vietnam and Persian Gulf wars, U.S. officials regularly claimed to be interested in "negotiations," when in reality they were only ready to accept surrender. With patriotic gullibility the media swallowed the official propaganda claims and helped pave the way for war and the prolongation of war. At Rambouillet, NATO offered Yugoslavia an ultimatum that included NATO's right to occupy all of Yugoslavia. This offer was one no sovereign nation could accept and was designed to be rejected. But just as in the earlier cases, the media accepted the false official claim that Milosevic rather than NATO was unwilling to negotiate or accept reasonable terms. And once again the media helped pave the way for war.

Rule of law: This is a purr phrase, that is used only when convenient. During the Persian Gulf war, at which time the Bush administration could get Security Council agreement for action against Iraq, President Bush declared that the issue at stake was the "rule of law" versus the law of the jungle. However, at the time of the U.S. incursion into Panama in 1989, when Security Council approval was not obtainable and the incursion was in clear violation of the OAS agreement, the matter of law was muted. Similarly, unable to obtain Security Council approval for the NATO attack on Yugoslavia, with the attack in evident violation of the UN Charter, and with U.S. participation eventually in violation of the War Powers Act, U.S. and NATO officials were singularly uninterested in questions of law. And the U.S. mainstream media cooperated by setting this issue aside as well. They now ignore their old favorite Alexander Solzhenitsyn, who says today that "The aggressors have kicked aside the UN, opening a new era where might is right."

Genocide and ethnic cleansing: These snarl words have been frequently applied to the Serbs, helping justify the NATO war. In a recent masterpiece of propaganda (June 13, 1999), New York Times reporter Michael Wines explains that "Fifty-four years after the Holocaust revelations, America and Europe had finally said 'enough,' and struck a blow against a revival of genocide." The West found a "revival of genocide" in a locale where some 2000 people had been killed in the year prior to the NATO attack, which inspired those great moralists Clinton and Blair to act. If this seems like a relatively small number in the light of other modern day slaughters, Wines advises us that "there is a yawning gap between the West and much of the world on the value of a single life." The West is concerned with each individual life, so 2000 can understandably activate its sensitive leaders.

Wines does not mention that Clinton and Blair are the leaders supporting the sanctions against Iraq that, at the time they had "had enough" of genocide in Kosovo, had killed a million Iraqi civilians. Blair is still the biggest arms supplier to Indonesia, and both the moralists sell arms to and are on entirely friendly terms with the Turkish government that has ethnically cleansed Kurds on a large scale for many years. The greatest single case of ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia in the 1990s occurred at Krajina in Croatia in 1995, where several hundred thousand Serbs were put to flight and many killed. This action was done with U.S. and NATO aid and was not objected to in any way by NATO.

In short, U.S. and NATO policy toward Kosovo has been riddled with contradictions and hypocrisies, and has enlarged a local human rights crisis to a regional disaster. This has been helped by a system of doublespeak that the mainstream media have not only failed to challenge but have incorporated into their own usage. Contrary to their proclaimed objectivity, this failure has made them agents of state propaganda, rather than information servants of a democratic community. _

 

 

 

     

 


Questions? Contact me.

All materials unless otherwise indicated are copyright © 2001 by Stacy Tartar Esch.
The original contents of this site may not be reproduced, republished, reused, or retransmitted
without the express written consent of Stacy Tartar Esch.
These contents are for educational purposes only.