para sirve metoprolol 95 mg meloxicam for bladder cancer in dogs buy kamagra in france como cuanto cuesta la voltaren en ampolla en costa rica teva ondansetron 8 mg blue amaryllis bulbs for sale counterfeit viagra india seroquel 25 mg anwendung rn reciprocity in texas cialis 5 mg one time pharmacy cialis price misoprostol and mifepristone in philippines viagra shopping online generic cialis best prices india zoloft 25 mg and pregnancy unicure remedies pvt. ltd viagra india side effects seroquel 100 mg should you take topamax in the morning zovirax tablets australia prescription apo allopurinol 100 mg is it safe to take ibuprofen and adderall vardenafil buy metronidazole in encephalopathy nexium tablets canada viagra generic release date jaslene orlistat 120 mg generic nystatin triamcinolone how to buy albuterol for breathing machines cheapest generic viagra and canada cialis for daily use prices costco azithromycin used in gi motility zithromax buy online india prescription discount for cialis at cvs lariam available india is celexa a pain review diovan 80 mg composição donde comprar disulfiram lotensin bertibarots cost para que sirve omeprazole dr 40 mg generic pill for singulair side effects zantac liquid infants orlistat stada 120mg online what is wellbutrin called in the uk order azithromycin canada singulair 10 ml is permethrin safe in pregnancy how much does viagra cost with bcbs insurance price prednisone 5mg how long can you take fluconazole 100 mg to work kamagralondon reliable what is generic for accutane prix du viagra en turquie arava side effects in dogs much does vardenafil cost how long has voltaren gel been on the market cheap xenical overseas is benadryl gel caps safe for dogs linezolid in dogs 150mg cheap viagra hace falta receta medica para comprar cialis viagra 120 online amoxicillin and clavulanic acid safe in pregnancy is it ok to take 20 mg of cialis 2 days in a row is vermox safe for cats meclizine hcl manufacturer india methocarbamol cost walmart what is lovastatin 40 mg for provera 10 mg 10 dagar lexapro online without prescription topamax 50 mg 60 film tablet fiyat? who are women in cialis commercial why is viagra more effective in the morning costco renova cream how to get viagra in nz how to buy cialis with no prescription does trazodone have tylenol in it price of cialis and viagra purinethol 50 mg prix where to buy ciprofloxacin with no prescription vermox 100 mg erfahrungen where to buy synthroid dutasteride rowcmoadreders australia lamotrigine sleep disorder buy metronidazole 400mg x 14 how much does singulair cost in canada ibuprofen 600 mg ontstekingsremmend generic metformin whartisthebestin costa allegra seychellen clomiphene for men buy lipitor mgr cialis 5 mg eksi how to buy viagra in vancouver b.c. viagra tablet side effects in urdu finasteride 1 mg billiger lamisil once discount permethrin in soil cost depo provera walgreens buy betamethasone 1 reviews duloxetine hcl dr 30 mg cap cost cymbalta medication best statin to use with fenofibrate how often can i take a 800 mg ibuprofen where to buy quality generic viagra organic viagra australia zovirax 50 mg g price on nexium 40mg what is a cheaper alternative to nexium is it best to masturbate before taking cialis buy metronidazole cream without panadol comp 500 mg divalproex 500 mg street value introduccion de los actos procesales proscar on sale cardura xl 4 mg ne için kullan?l?r comprar viagra colombia 20 mg of cialis reviews priligy online purchase what happens if you put cefdinir in the fridge cheapest levitra canada trazodone 200 mg tab does topamax work for bipolar disorder can i buy viagra in kerala gabapentin 300 mg tab buying viagra over the counter canada cvs 40mg lisinopril price com qual idade pode usar viagra prozac nation reviews book indomethacin 25 mg and high blood pressure revista de indias articles marial iglesias utet doxycycline 1000 mg plavix tablets in japan amlodipine besylate 10 mg taken with 10 mg prednisone can i buy flagyl pills at clicks micardis plus 80 12.5 mg nas?l kullan?l?r celebrex discount coupon buy metronidazole 2g miami nizoral 2 shampoo in india comprar viagra seguro españa does expiration date on generic viagra mean anything baclofen tabletki 10 mg when not to give nitroglycerin in chest pain tadalafil citrate liquid 35 half life diflucan 150 mg amlodipine 10 prix nifedipine 60 mg price comprar kamagra oral jelly barata buy ciprofloxacin hc online no prescription can accutane prescriptions have refills is it safe to take two 10gm cialis at one time shemale generic cialis phenergan storing up in fat cells prednisone 15 mg per day diflucan 450 mg for nail cialis for longer in bee took 2 claritin in 24 hours levonorgestrel in uae levofloxacino 1500 mg is it safe to drink alcohol and clarithromycin long does 20 mg cialis work what is macrobid in spanish can you take benadryl with montelukast 10 mg generic cialis next day delivery us what is the dose of diflucan for yeast infection in men no rx. viagra reviews of wellbutrin xr fosamax 70 mg tablets how much does amoxicillin cost chlamydia in dogs treatment azithromycin zyprexa 10 mg wirkung albuterol buy yahpo answers how often can you take 600 mg of motrin fluoxetine 20 mg and pregnancy prilosec safe use daily macrobid contraindications in pregnancy 5 mg cialis once day prices levitra orosolubile costo dexamethasone use in lambs best generic viagra forums paxil mg diflucan 150 mg primjena ramipril 5 mg zuzahlung how many mg is otc ibuprofen atenolol brands in india rocaltrol in chronic renal failure ciproglen 500 mg for dogs cymbalta zusammensetzung boots the chemist withdraw phenergan betamethasone ointment walmart fincar cheap buy lasix amex online does avodart have generic amoxicillin for toddlers cost albendazole suspension brands cymbalta and fibromyalgia reviews viagra when to take it for the best results buy clomid 50mg online in mumbai india bactrim ds price levitra and cialis together safe doxycycline hyclate 50 mg tier inipomp 20 mg pantoprazole omeprazole tablet 40 mg quero comprar o xenical orlistat 200mg sotalol 40 mg prospect phenytoin capsule to liquid conversion floxin dergboadre australia metformin generic form amoxicillin for cats liquid losartan potassium 100 mg tablet ranitidine for constipation in cats 150 mg prednisone side effects escitalopram teva ireland how long propranolol stay in your system viagra plus cialis which is best enlargement zantac safe use daily buy clomid 100mg escitalopram withdrawal symptoms canada walmart pricing viagra pink viagra review lamisil 250 mg night sweats pesquisa actos online zyrtec 10 mg cheap buy clomid australia online medicament cordarone 200 mg acquistare cialis 10 mg can you take paracetamol and ibuprofen in hand luggage zoloft class action lawsuit canada safe take ibuprofen melatonin metronidazole dg gel safe during pregnancy for gum pain metformina clorhidrato 850 mg ?para bajar de peso over counter viagra turkey is it safe to alternate aleve and ibuprofen kamagra 100 gold 100 mg review tretinoin mizha buy valium levitra etodolac lodine 400 mg tablet 40 mg prozac and weight loss reviews of abilify for depression zocor 80 mg warning buy azithromycin 250mg online how much does zovirax tablets cost dove posso acquistare viagra online prednisone 10 mg 12 day best?lla kamagra billigt buy imitrex migraine feldene 40 mg injetavel bula does plavix have sulfer in it gabapentin 500 mg per day opiate withdrawal voltaren prices verapamil sr reviews methotrexate safe dosage propranolol 10 mg once daily sertraline price in india amoxil suspension de 250 mg socialist countries going bankrupt preciso receita comprar viagra lamictal 300 mg daily cabergoline hereisthebestin australia finasteride 5 mg instead of propecia ivermectin bertibarots australia diflucan sale almaximo sildenafil 50 mg que es viagra for sale cheap can you buy viagra over the counter in a chemist propranolol vaistai 20 mg phenytoin loading dose in obesity luvox preço 50 mg aciclovir crema 100 mg xenical 120 mg gélules can i mix amoxicillin in food ibuprofen tablets in bangladesh who discovered antibiotic erythromycin buy fake viagra in manila can you buy viagra in a uk chemist safety of zofran and pregnancy buy tadalafil nederland losartan hennig 50 mg preis buy depo provera naproxen 250 mg tablet tev does prednisone cause weakness in muscles selegiline purchase online how much is generic singulair in north of ireland diovan marketing strategy liquid doxycycline for dogs drugs can i buy viagra at atlanta best cialis deal se vende cialis generico en mexico cheapest.co.uk viagra prednisolone bp vet 5 mg side effects nolvadex 20mg uk kamagra .co.uk free delivery buying cialis boots how to buy effexor online dose of thyroxine in hypothyroidism generic viagra australia forum is amoxicillin antibiotics good in early pregnancy efectos secundarios de montelukast 4 mg safe cialis viagra medroxyprogesterone 10 mg tablet amlodipine 5 mg color prometrium 100 mg to delay period misoprostol price australia how much benadryl can a dog have in 24 hours finpecia generics24 where to purchase colchicine price zyprexa discount brand viagra by pfizer can you bring nolvadex back to australia from thailand voltaren 50 mg y alcohol pris cialis 20 mg cardizem off market 150 mg zantac side effects crestor 10 mg equivalent to lipitor diltiazem in myocardial infarction can i use both minoxidil and finasteride in course effects of clindamycin in dogs safely stop lisinopril para que es el clonidine 0.1 mg clindamycin gel buy online cialis 20 mg prezzi farmacia viagra in rsa which brand of ibuprofen dissolves the quickest levaquin use in canines warfarin 5 mg daily shortness of breath prednisone 10 mg medication metronidazole 250 mg what does venlafaxine 75 mg look like protonix 40 mg uses how long does propranolol last in the body luvox cr for panic disorder wo kaufe ich viagra generika nitrofurantoin brand name india is cialis 5 mg dangerous at 41 year old where to find viagra montreal clindamycin 150 mg msds orlistat generico mk gabapentin side effects in teenagers nolvadex reviews by men wlamrt price of levitra use of amitriptyline in elderly diovan marketing strategy what can happen if you take 1600 mg of ibuprofen levaquin 250 mg uti ibuprofen 800 mg and benadryl amoxicillin is safe for breastfeeding price of keflex at walgreens vardenafil hydrochloride manufacturer in india savitra cialis brand overnight delivery isotretinoin pills mg tab paroxetine in treatment of early ejaculation levitra rowcmoadreders discount tamoxifen 10 mg twice daily doxycycline hyclate price in philippines accutane lawsuit colitis canada brand name topiramate misoprostol online paypal account white man in cialis advertisment is plavix drugs generic from canada is safe metformin hcl 100 mg clomid success rate 150 mg gabapentin in hot flashes cymbalta 60 mg information carbamazepine dose in pregnancy minocycline safe alcohol can you take 50mg viagra twice in one day generic version alesse doxazosin side effects reviews efek samping viagra australia can i take 800 mg of naproxen shoppers drug mart buy viagra premarin side effects uk aripiprazole india amaryl 4 mg price in india counterfeit cialis pill 250 mg or 500 mg amoxicillin does benadryl have codeine in it brand name of metronidazole in bangladesh is lisinopril generic for diovan can celebrex be bought over the counter levitra 20 mg fiyatlari how to buy zithromax online clomid metformin without prescription cheap generic betamethasone 0.05 buy online uk can you buy viagra in mens toilets buy antibiotics metronidazole and doxycycline online uk flomax 350 mg granulato come si prende finasteride 5 mg peru diovan hct sale coumadin 4 mg color is it safe to take cialis and valium together donde comprar viagra en santiago sin receta doxycycline chlamydia buy uk lipitor or crestor which is safer where to buy nolvadex or arimidex metformina clorhidrato 850 mg mecanismo de accion generic synthroid making me sick para que se usa nexium 40 mg getting viagra ireland betamethasone valerate scalp application price how much celebrex can you take in 1 day 500 mg cipro strep throat can you get diamox uk 200 mg of elavil does robaxin show up in urine test amitriptyline 25 mg vidal tratamiento aciclovir 200 mg abilify in sarcina fosamax generic form meloxicam 7.5 mg high paroxetine 20 mg for depression accutane 40 mg once day compare finasteride price price cialis in copenhagen ratio meloxicam 15 mg costco price wellbutrin xl nhs viagra shop uk cost of viagra from walgreens bupropion sr 150 mg green can you take paroxetine in the morning generic cialis shipped to canada what is the maximum safe dose of metformin viagra200 mg online ibuprofen 600 mg contiene aspirina does cymbalta really work pain is methotrexate available in nigeria sildenafil 100 mg viagra purchase vibramycin whartisthebestin clopidogrel generic and tooth extraction azathioprine side effects australia side effects of metronidazole 500mg in dogs misoprostol in italia atorvastatin 10mg price per sheet reviews on cialis vs. viagra prednisone in copd generic vs brand name wellbutrin sr natural alternatives to viagra australia levothroid comprar voltaren 100 diclofenac natr in diabetics is valtrex safe to take long term flexiver meloxicam 15 mg side effects amoxil 500 price philippines doxycycline 100 mg capsules efecto secundario daily usage of metformin hytrocloride defects wellbutrin 150 mg online kamagra in thailand kaufen clindamycin phosphate gel for acne price generic cialis mexican pharmacy use of cetirizine hydrochloride in pregnancy does zovirax come generic amlodipine besylate 2.5 mg tabs side effects buy clomid whartisthebestin bactrim ds price clomid hubei real fake panadol extra price in india fosinopril hctz brand name where to buy clotrimazole and betamethasone best diet to eat while on coumadin neurontin 8000 mg yan etkileri where to buy 2 ketoconazole shampoo can a person live with stent in the heart use cialis buy motilium australia flomax cost walgreens precio strattera 60 en usa what std can bactrim 800 mg treat doxycycline 100 mg rosacea is paracetamol or ibuprofen best for fever lipitor in acute coronary syndrome order cialis aciclovir safe online doxycycline canada dogs augmentin medsafe datasheet metoprolol xl 200 mg over the counter name for meclizine bactrim generics street price of 50mg viagra does viagra really work men safety of apotex generic lipitor equivalent decadron 0.25 mg licorice powder introduccion a los actos procesales 100 mg cialis dosage options when is it best to take viagra clonidine in spinal anaesthesia unterschied zwischen kamagra uk viagra dexamethasone uses in animals what is esomeprazole tablets ip 40 mg for levitra anvisa prochlorperazine supp 25 mg how much voltaren can you take in a day zithromax 500 mg for sinusitis mathod evaluated dispersible linezolide 400 mg tablets generic medications for lipitor cialis tadalafil 20 mg side effects are there any generic viagra lisinopril alternatives in indian amoxicillin 875 mg and dizziness can you buy viagra off the shelf aciclovir tablets australia will ibuprofen 800 mg make you sleepy is it safe for humans to take dog prednisone where can i purchase periactin pills benzac ac gel buy can hydroxyzine 10 mg be stopped cold turkey


Brainstorm
Services

EDUCATIONAL
MATERIALS

West Chester University

Fall 2001

Spring 2002

West Chester University

Fall 2002

 

Home

Course Information
  Lit 165 Syllabus
  ENG 020 Syllabus
  About the Instructor

Notes for Introduction to Literature
  Approaching Literature
  Notes on the Art of Fiction: Early Forms
  The Short Story
  Graduate Students Define the Art of Fiction
  Bartleby the Scrivener - Questions for Analysis
  Notes on Melville
  Critical Approaches to Literature
  A Vocabulary for Short Fiction and Beyond
  Study Guide for Fiction Exam
  Reading Poetry
  The Craft of Poetry
  A Catalogue of Poems
  Notes on Langston Hughes
  Lines of Continuity
  Poetry Take Home Exam
  The Birth of Drama
  Oedipus
  A Doll House
  Study Guide for the Final Exam
  A Glossary of Literary Terms

Notes for Basic Writing (ENG 020)
  The Rhetorical Situation
  Essay #1 Assignment Sheet
  Workshop Assignment for Essay#1
  How to Write Descriptively
  Building a Thesis
  Overcoming Reader's Block
  Analysis and the Culture of Advertising
  Essay #2 Assignment Sheet
  Writing Effective Introductions
  Writing Effective Conclusions
  Propaganda Analysis
  Politics and the English Language
  Propaganda: A Sample Analysis
  Midterm Exam: Tips for Writing on the Spot
  Notes on Rational Argument
  Mapping the Parts of an Arugment

General Announcements
  Announcements for LIT 165
  Assignments for LIT 165
  Announcements for ENG 020
  Assignments for ENG 020

Contact

Go Exploring
  A Weblog for LIT 165
  A Weblog for ENG 020

Join the Conversation
  LIT 165 Discussion List
  ENG 020 Discussion List

 

~~ Propaganda: A Sample Analysis ~~

From Zmag.org's archive of commentaries, here's a sample analysis of the propaganda which surrounded NATO's military action in Kosovo (Yugolsavia) in the Spring, 1999.

KOSOVO AND DOUBLESPEAK
By Edward S. Herman
June 15, 1999

War, propaganda, and the proliferation of doublespeak have always gone hand-in-hand. As was the case during the Persian Gulf war, the NATO war against Yugoslavia witnessed a collapse of mainstream media integrity and a new surge of doublespeak in the service of the war party. It was grimly humorous that NATO and its compliant media partners justified the bombing of Serbian radio and TV on the grounds of propaganda service to Milosevic's war machine. In reality, the parallel service of the U.S. and British media differed from that of the Serbs mainly in their ludicrous self- designation as objective and propaganda-free.

Let me briefly review here a short-list of purr and snarl words that have been of outstanding service to U.S. and British propaganda.

Credibility: Credibility is a purr word, that oozes goodness. Hawks always resort to credibility as a form of flag-waving, using it to make compromise or withdrawal a form of moral and unpatriotic defeat. But it is an appeal to irrationality and assures that a mistake can be transformed into a catastrophe. The media have been extremely lax in giving uncontested space to Senator John McCain and Zbigniew Brzezinski to play the credibility gambit and failing to look behind this purr word to the real issues at stake. And they have thereby allowed it to serve as an instrument of war propaganda.

Humanitarian bombing: NATO allegedly began bombing in March for humanitarian purposes. Humanitarian is a purr word, but humanitarian bombing is an oxymoron, blending the warm-hearted with dealing death. As the NATO bombing exponentially increased the damage inflicted on the purported beneficiaries, as well as large numbers of innocent Serb civilians, it has been anti-humanitarian at all levels. The CIA and NATO military officials like General Wesley Clark have admitted that the negative humanitarian effects were expected. The phrase is a propaganda fraud covering over a hidden agenda, in which Kosovo Albanian welfare had little or no place. But the media have never considered the phrase an oxymoron or the policy a human rights fraud.

Victory: With the end of the bombing, the media trumpet the official view that NATO won a "victory," but they do not ask whether this triumph was in fulfilment of the alleged humanitarian aim--they have implicitly abandoned that purported objective in favor of celebrating a mighty military victory over another tiny and overmatched enemy power. The NATO and media celebration recalls George Santayana's words: "Fanaticism consists in redoubling your effort when you have forgotten your aim."

Military targets: NATO repeatedly claimed that it was avoiding civilian and sticking to military targets. However, it steadily expanded the definition of military target to encompass anything that directly or indirectly helped the Serb war effort, so that electric and water facilities (among other things) primarily serving civilians were included as military targets. This is in violation of international law and the army's own rules of warfare, and therefore amounts to the commission of war crimes. Christopher Simpson recently cited a President's Commission on Critical Infrastructure Protection finding that the bombing of electric and water facilities in U.S. cities would be criminal "terrorism." The media have of course never mentioned this report, which suggests that NATO engaged in wholesale criminal terrorism, and they have treated the commission of war crimes with the lightest touch. In fact, pundits like Thomas Friedman of the New York Times have urged the direct bombing of civilians and thus the commission of war crimes.

Collateral damage: This is our old friend from the Vietnam and Persian Gulf wars. It purrs, suggesting inadvertence and "errors." But where the likelihood of "errors" in a bombing raid have a probability of over 90 percent, the damage is intentional even if the particular victims were not targeted. If somebody throws a bomb at an individual in a crowded theater, and 100 bystanders are also killed, would we say that the bomb thrower was not clearly guilty of killing the 100 because their deaths were "unintended" and the damage was "collateral"? The propaganda agencies reserve such purr word excuses for "humanitarian" bombing.

Negotiations: During the Vietnam and Persian Gulf wars, U.S. officials regularly claimed to be interested in "negotiations," when in reality they were only ready to accept surrender. With patriotic gullibility the media swallowed the official propaganda claims and helped pave the way for war and the prolongation of war. At Rambouillet, NATO offered Yugoslavia an ultimatum that included NATO's right to occupy all of Yugoslavia. This offer was one no sovereign nation could accept and was designed to be rejected. But just as in the earlier cases, the media accepted the false official claim that Milosevic rather than NATO was unwilling to negotiate or accept reasonable terms. And once again the media helped pave the way for war.

Rule of law: This is a purr phrase, that is used only when convenient. During the Persian Gulf war, at which time the Bush administration could get Security Council agreement for action against Iraq, President Bush declared that the issue at stake was the "rule of law" versus the law of the jungle. However, at the time of the U.S. incursion into Panama in 1989, when Security Council approval was not obtainable and the incursion was in clear violation of the OAS agreement, the matter of law was muted. Similarly, unable to obtain Security Council approval for the NATO attack on Yugoslavia, with the attack in evident violation of the UN Charter, and with U.S. participation eventually in violation of the War Powers Act, U.S. and NATO officials were singularly uninterested in questions of law. And the U.S. mainstream media cooperated by setting this issue aside as well. They now ignore their old favorite Alexander Solzhenitsyn, who says today that "The aggressors have kicked aside the UN, opening a new era where might is right."

Genocide and ethnic cleansing: These snarl words have been frequently applied to the Serbs, helping justify the NATO war. In a recent masterpiece of propaganda (June 13, 1999), New York Times reporter Michael Wines explains that "Fifty-four years after the Holocaust revelations, America and Europe had finally said 'enough,' and struck a blow against a revival of genocide." The West found a "revival of genocide" in a locale where some 2000 people had been killed in the year prior to the NATO attack, which inspired those great moralists Clinton and Blair to act. If this seems like a relatively small number in the light of other modern day slaughters, Wines advises us that "there is a yawning gap between the West and much of the world on the value of a single life." The West is concerned with each individual life, so 2000 can understandably activate its sensitive leaders.

Wines does not mention that Clinton and Blair are the leaders supporting the sanctions against Iraq that, at the time they had "had enough" of genocide in Kosovo, had killed a million Iraqi civilians. Blair is still the biggest arms supplier to Indonesia, and both the moralists sell arms to and are on entirely friendly terms with the Turkish government that has ethnically cleansed Kurds on a large scale for many years. The greatest single case of ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia in the 1990s occurred at Krajina in Croatia in 1995, where several hundred thousand Serbs were put to flight and many killed. This action was done with U.S. and NATO aid and was not objected to in any way by NATO.

In short, U.S. and NATO policy toward Kosovo has been riddled with contradictions and hypocrisies, and has enlarged a local human rights crisis to a regional disaster. This has been helped by a system of doublespeak that the mainstream media have not only failed to challenge but have incorporated into their own usage. Contrary to their proclaimed objectivity, this failure has made them agents of state propaganda, rather than information servants of a democratic community. _

 

 

 

     

 


Questions? Contact me.

All materials unless otherwise indicated are copyright © 2001 by Stacy Tartar Esch.
The original contents of this site may not be reproduced, republished, reused, or retransmitted
without the express written consent of Stacy Tartar Esch.
These contents are for educational purposes only.