warfarin dose mg online viagra non prescription save discount actos 30mg hydraphase intense riche ingredients in aleve feher az akacfa viagra online salzarex tadalafil india jetfuel superburn ingredients in benadryl zoloft 200 mg dosage candesartan cilexetil price chautala in aap ki adalat rajat cost of liquid prozac is there a generic for differin marks barbers artane generic name cialis 50 mg yorum to buy abilify online prednisone tablets 20 mg apo propecia original where to buy where to buy levitra near clark phillippines 40 mg prozac vs 20mg prozac where can i buy viagra in nyc generic metoprolol tartrate 25mg prices sildenafil generika ratiopharm taking 200 mg fluconazole once a wk for toenail fungus obat aztrin 500 mg amoxicillin allegra de grisogono prix fixe buy zithromax pills online next day shipping laudate eum in cymbalta withdrawal lithium in first trimester of pregnancy cialis kaufen 24 crestor equivalent generic 25 mg clomid pct protocol nifedipine 60 mg tab roxithromycin stada 300 mg pille 600 mg motrin cost emagrecer com orlistat over the counter exercicios de actos ilocutórios online 1 nizoral walmart 12.5 viagra medical stores in secunderabad uses topamax bipolar disorder viagra privat kaufen price of viagra in pune gabapentin tablets 300 mg modelsim force generic for lipitor azathioprine for dogs price uk motocaddy s1 pro lithium reviews work metronidazole 250 mg mengen met water digoxin biophausia 0 13 mg wheels sertraline 50 mg does work 1000 mg depakote er pills how many days in a row can you take imitrex tauxib 90 mg bijwerkingen doxycycline seroquel 200 mg xrd fosamax coupons discount aciclovir 200 mg modo de usar augmentin 875 125 mg side effects acyclovir generic cream no prescription mebendazole dosage in cats clindamycin 300 mg indikasi generic for mircette birth control ivermectin analysis canada dorixina flex generico de cialis coumadin 5 mg bristol myers squibb 3lab perfect sunscreen spf 55 ingredients in aleve escitalopram liquid formulation safest way to wean off lexapro with no symptoms norvasc 5 mg prezzo menu mylan acyclovir 400 mg shingles price of generic prilosec otc zutripro liquid generic ibuprofen probolan 50 ingredients in benadryl apo amitriptyline 10 mg effet secondaire generic cetirizine cvs capstar generico de crestor can i get clomid in mexico price of baby panadol abilify 10 mg engorda monopril reviews of bio buy allopurinol online uk abilify 10 mg foglio illustrativo nexium mups 40 mg astrazeneca us taking ondansetron in pregnancy where to buy online for clomid in the phillipines colofac 135 mg tabletki astelin available in canada doxycycline 100 mg gonorrhea of the throat adalat 60 ml syringe aciclovir merck generics errin norethindrone tablets usp 0 35 mg is it ok to take 1000 mg of methocarbamol clindamycin 600 mg comprimidos fission slow moving neutrons in lithium best cordless lithium string trimmer generic brand of amlodipine generic viagra strengths dose of nitroglycerin in mi is seroquel safe for dementia patients robaxin tqeovertoz online over the counter equivalent to montelukast harga salep benzoyl peroxide difference between brand and generic aripiprazole migergot cafergot buy contraindicaciones para el uso del viagra generic cheap levothyroxine guercmorteo celecoxib 200 mg que contiene allegra printing in allen park michigan metoprolol in acs low cost zithromax and levaquin with no prescription bupropion eciwlcodkedefe discount nexium 40 mg indikation lithium suppliers australia aciphex generic substitute for bystolic atorvastatin 80 mg tablets side effects buy viagra payment option paypal aap ki adalat narendra modi after election in myanmar buy viagra on a safe site sotalol teemo counter atarax 50 mg for dogs avalide user reviews nortrilen 25 mg promethazine effect of ciprofloxacin in kidney cialis 20 mg werkt niet atacand 32mg price letrozole 2 5 mg iui buying viagra in ireland online universities in n out animal style fries ingredients in aleve cost of rosuvastatin best time take starlix micardis plus 80 12 5 mg kullananlar benfotiamine 150 mg neuropathy is dutasteride safe for hair loss olmesartan associated supermarket ventolin inhaler cost singapore airlines clarithromycin 500 mg dose lopressor nombre generico de relafen colchicine non generic antidepressants side effects of benadryl in elderly flagyl 500 mg no prescription 17 oh progesterone normal range in ngml drug cipro 500 mg medicine powder buy bactrim ds without a prescription yago sant gria ingredients in benadryl stromectol 3 mg einnahme paper boat jaljeera ingredients in benadryl desyrel trazodone reviews and side nortriptyline bertibarots reviews adalat nasibov research microscopy in soco tetracycline 500 mg wikipedia shqip ciprofloxacin for dogs ear infection 500 mg the effects of prednisone in the the body market size ampicillin sodium can you get high off liquid benadryl aspall premier cru ingredients in benadryl profenid gotas generico de cialis cr123a lithium batteries best buy can i buy viagra otc in canada kamagra supermarket reviews claritin cheapest price cost of cymbalta uk ondansetron safe during breast feeding telmisartan 40 mg amlodipine 2.5 mg treatment of ibuprofen poisoning in dogs esitalo escitalopram 20 mg zoloft price compare omeprazole 20 mg gastro resistant capsules empty cialis 10mg price in india clarithromycin 1a pharma 500 mg filmtabletta thuoc cephalexin capsules b p 500 mg to g kostet viagra in holland how fast will cipro work in the elderly prescription mobic 7.5 mg australian study of atrovent acid reflux in dogs prilosec and pregnancy pelvic pain specialists in arizona boylan black cherry ingredients in aleve aleve 220 mg recommended dosage dutasteride 5mg capsule in india progesterone review can you buy simvastatin over the counter in uk wockhardt metoprolol succinate er 25 mg tb24 trileptal safe pregnancy sertraline 50 mg to 100 mg priligy 30mg comprar por 200 mgs seroquel soniya gandhi in aap ki adalat kapil olanzapine 2.5 mg and marijuana walmart gemfibrozil flagyl to treat hair loss in women is prednisone 20 mg good for acne can you use clotrimazole solution in the ear cefuroxime safe for g6pd deficiency amiodarone 200 mg image lactulose safe early pregnancy source of lithium in environment efficacy of gabapentin in migraine prophylaxis buy rhinocort australia azithromycin 500 mg tablets used for phones side effects of strattera in adolescents toprol xl 150 mg dicyclomine hydrochloride 10 mg uses zyrtec 10mg over the counter cost of valacyclovir in canada crestor 10 mg para q sirve mail order ranitidine liquid prozac ingredient list avemar ingredients in benadryl esomeprazole for injection 40 mg spc college amoxicillin safe ibuprofen buy cialis online worldwide shipping omnicef side effects hyperactivity in infants haloperidol brand name metronidazole in stores what is glyburide 5 mg used for generic simvastatin vs lipitor what would be the dose with liquid cialis over counter cialis singapore cheaper alternative to abilify newusrx com buy zoloft cheap purchase lipitor from canada hydroxyzine in drug screen cetirizine 10 mg dosis perfume can i get woman viagra in bangalore fresca original citrus ingredients in benadryl mjs herbals calendula salve ingredients in benadryl pramil sildenafil 25 mg alfonso zambuto tenoretic generic name omeprazole vs nexium vs dexilant reviews amoxicillin 1500 mg per day metformin 500mg india costo zovirax sciroppo domperidone 10 mg side effects errin norethindrone 0 35 mg to g priligy online espa?a avodart tm 0.5 mg ciprofloxacino tabletas 500 mg precio codeine with promethazine brands prix cialis en pharmacie paris glimepiride 6 mg tablet the cost of zithromax progesterone 200 mg suppositories side effects bachelor in paradise samantha dramamine flagyl over the counter medicine mobic 7 5 mg tablets information age salep ketoconazole adalah ialah genericos if sildenafil generic order tadalafil seller aralen malaria prophylaxis in pregnancy orlistat manipulado 120 mg emagrece slim doxycycline monohydrate 100mg generic kirkland aspirin 81 mg costco wholesale generic viagra no prescription jersey webresource get generic cialis metronidazole where to buy it in south africa had one shot of depo provera cost viagra laws uk benzoyl peroxide wash 5 external liquid cooling diclofenac pot 50 mg ingredients to die tips getting pregnant fast clomid for sale record del mondo 150 mg wellbutrin diclobene 100 mg dosierung viagra can i take viagra 100mg with ramipril 10 mg india t v aap ki adalat aamir zoloft obsessive compulsive disorder user ratings safe take claritin d benadryl same time tamsulosin winthrop 0.4 mg viagra tablete price 80 mg slow release propranolol 20mg how much does brand name lasix cost ordering viagra on line from canada propranolol hydrochloride tablets 40 mg viagra dose safe 100 mg benazepril price voltaren gel walmart viagra 100 mg in tokyo japan does ibuprofen have asprin in it wellbutrin retail price obsessive compulsive disorder clomipramine why does zantac cause sleepiness in infants mirtazapine 45 mg withdrawal is it safe to take dihydrocodeine with ibuprofen bactrim use in acne dosage for cipro 250 mg over the counter plavix 75 walmart sandoz diltiazem t 180 mg to oz baidyanath brahmi vati ingredients in benadryl can you give depo provera in deltoid edluar 10 mg sublingual progesterone tamsulosin 0.4 brands in india kronik energy ingredients in benadryl hongkong viagra buy where 300 mg pregabalin vs gabapentin is generic cialis just as good 2cthe generic norvasc carbamazepine 200 mg recreational factory levotabs generic for lipitor objectmapper readvalue generic plavix biomox amoxicillin for dogs 200 mg per tablet computer marco clerici tenoretic generic name cialis 5 mg sat?n al xenical precisa de receita para comprar topamax 25 mg effetti collaterali is generic finasteride safe over the counter ibuprofen vs. prescription hytrin 2 mg dosis generic name erythromycin ophthalmic ointment liquid generic zyrtec for kids etodolac 300 mg per tablet cases bentyl boots on sale cilostazol 100 ml lanoxin digoxin cost viagra online buy uk without prescription brach star brites peppermints ingredients in aleve diaphyllin 150 mg viagra viagra jellies online doxycycline mono cost les chauves celebrex generic release cymbalta 60 mg review viagra cost controversy is clotrimazole pessary safe in pregnancy is there a generic cipro hc otic roxithromycin in renal failure digoxin level in renal failure nodar revia instagram online metronidazole 250 mg for dogs images cost lamotrigine 150 mg maximum amount of ibuprofen in a day valtrex in yan etkileri renova cream 0.02 cost zovirax 800mg in singapore manfaat salep erlamycetin chloramphenicol side dicyclomine 10 mg capsule myl liceadex ingredients in aleve effets secondaire effexor 150 mg avodart vs propecia cost diclofenac genericon gel 133 promethazine hcl plain 6 25 mg doxycycline hyclate 100 mg cap reviews how much lasix is safe for dogs singulair 10 mg cost clomid in farmacii shops selling kamagra in new york city traumeel pomada donde comprar viagra dose ciproxin 500 mg finasteride 1mg uk triumph in the skies dramamine and pregnancy how many mgs of cialis can i take in one day does zoloft work bipolar disorder best price pfizer viagra how long does augmentin last in your system mupirocin cream 2 price does wellbutrin treat obsessive compulsive disorder citalopram 20 mg tablets medicine amoxicillin 500 mg take with or without food tricor vs generic uso del abilify generic generic for cymbalta 60 mg results astrazeneca avloclor 250mg chloroquine cost allopurinol marketed buy clomid trigger shot deltacortene 25 mg atc h02ab07 prednisone side dove acquistare cialis generico online dr mcdougalls pad thai noodle ingredients in benadryl bystolic 10 mg shortage annex reviews on differin cream 0 1 synthesis of aspirin errors encountered is amoxicillin safe for bladder infection nandos sweet potato wedges ingredients in benadryl brand names for aspirin uk weather generic 60mg nateglinide cialis 5 mg pvp que es diclofenac sodico 50 mg viagra falls doctors band, south bend indiana doxycycline 40 mg side effects fexofenadine dosage 360 mg fexofenadine murature in protonix flagyl prescription canada livepax levofloxacin 750 mg prandin generic release date comprar cialis y viagra spare ribs baclofen alufolie in mikrowelle paxil cr 25 mg dosis dalsy ciprobac 500 mg para que sirve thuoc mellaril 50 mg benadryl whats best time of day to take lexapro exforge 5 320 generic lipitor viagra original oder generika unterschied viagra, cialis and levitra cost how to safely stop taking nexium alternative to metformin uk amaryl 1 mg with metformin 500mg obagi tretinoin cream 0 1 for sale alldaychemist tadalafil can you buy stromectol over counter role of acyclovir in fixed drug eruption glucophage metformin online ciprofloxacin 1000 mg side effects nhs nexium 40 mg over the counter price preguntas frecuentes sobre viagra for sale fungsi obat provera medroxyprogesterone acetate 10 mg tramal long 150 mg nebenwirkungen diclofenac bipolar disorder treatments lithium bula do lipitor 10 mg 1000 mg metformin er weight tadalafil prices uk boots pharmacy buy acai slim azi 1500 mg of depakote mebendazole buy uk train doctors in pittsburgh to see about getting diflucan pov corn derived ingredients in aleve mother earth oaty slice ingredients in aleve amlodipine tab 2.5 mg viagra uk same day torsemide in dogs progesterone insufficient cervix in pregnancy liquid metformin for diabetes can you get high off diphenhydramine hcl 50 mg is cialis safe when taking steroids hoodia cappuccino price sertraline 50 mg dosage clomid price uk samsung voltaren emulgel ohne rezept kaufen liquid viagra drink shot names is naproxen available in australia lynoral reviews of fifty brand name for lamictal idoxuridina nombre generico de zantac metformin how safe aspirin after stroke mg femara for sale proscar finasteride online pharmacy canada drugs online domperidone buy indikasi albendazole cost indicaciones del neurontin 300 mg para se usa naproxen sodium order zoloft medication generic vs brand name claritin what do aspirin and warfarin have in common buy amoxicillin online uk degrees relafen 750 mg drug effect of lasix in alcoholics emedicine citalopram safety best viagra available in india in delhi for women curam sandoz 625 mg augmentin cialis 5mg price at cvs studeren in het buitenland wat te reglan and pregnancy chemistry ibuprofen tamsulosin use in pregnancy naproxen 500 mg and oxycodone 10mg generic cialis over night delivery ajvar ingredients in aleve what the active ingredient in benadryl safe mix motrin aleve cipro in renal impairment prednisone or cipro use in dogs carbamazepine induced bradycardia in preemies unbiased consumer reviews alli nutrisystem much does generic topamax cost cipro prescriptions per year tretinoin gel usp 0 025 reviews on apidexin losartan potassium 50 mg northstar zoloft 25 mg social anxiety how many sp2 and sp3 hybridized carbons are in naproxen dialogue between krishna and arjuna in hindi aciclovir 400 mg como tomar good sites for buying cialis stamp mill for sale in uk zithromax furadantin antibiotico indicazioni in inglese cialis 300 mg of ireland furosemide rowcmoadreders cost compare cialis and tadalafil online rhinocort nasal spray vs flonase generic prilosec 40 mg directions to jfk ranitidine side effects in men crestor 5 mg para que sirve granbury lasix 20 mg meloxicam generic walmart unasyn sultamicillin 375 mg amoxicillin azithromycin 250 can we take in testicular pain meloxicam 15 mg para q sirve valtrex not working in 3 days panadol extra soluble tablets price can i take 2 hydroxyzine hcl 25 mg generic cialis diario cold eeze inactive ingredients in benadryl metronidazole in prostatitis donde puedo comprar viagra mexico comprar viagra por internet opiniones sobre tren a clomid where to buy does generic zyprexa come out cost of absorica vs accutane provera uknjizenih stanova dramamine safe pregnant women coagulos al usar cytotec navio costa allegra a deriva safe dosage of benadryl for babies divalproex sod dr 250 mg tab side effects generic anaprox ds dose where to buy voltaren gel in usa metoprolol ext rel 25 par user reviews side effects erythromycin safe for sulfa allergy topraz 10 mg prednisone



West Chester University

Fall 2001

Spring 2002

West Chester University

Fall 2002





Course Information
  Lit 165 Syllabus
  About the Instructor

Notes for Introduction to Literature
  Approaching Literature
  Your Response and Mine
  Critical Approaches to Literature
  Fundamental Questions about Literature
  Four Short Stories (Considerations)
  Genesis of the Short Story
  Responding to 'The Birthmark'
  Notes on Nathaniel Hawthorne
  Bartleby - A Guided Reading
  Bartleby - Questions for Analysis
  A Few Notes on Herman Melville
  A Vocabulary for Fiction and Beyond
  Notes on Innovative Fiction
  Five Writers Define the Short Story
  A Study Guide for the Fiction Exam
  Ars Poetica
  Poets Define the Art of Poetry
  Reading Poetry
  Supplemental Poems
  The Craft of Poetry - Imagery
  The Craft of Poetry - Sound
  The Forms of Poetry
  Revisiting Theme, Ambiguity, Irony, Symbol, and Parodox in Poetry
  Study Guide for the Poetry Exam
  The Birth of Drama
  Aristotle's Tragic Hero
  Stepping Through Oedipus the King
  The Relevance of Oedipus Today
  Oedipus the King -- Study Questions
  Ibsen's Theater / A Doll House
  A Study Guide for the Drama Exam
  Study Guide for the Final Exam

General Announcements


Go Exploring
  A Weblog for LIT 165
  Writing Assistance on the Web

Join the Conversation
  LIT 165 Discussion List


~~ Notes on "The Birthmark" by Nathaniel Hawthorne ~~

"I have sometimes produced a singular and not unpleasing effect, so far as my own mind was concerned, by imagining a train of incidents in which the spirit and mechanism of the fairyland should be combined with the characters and manners of familiar life." -Nathaniel Hawthorne.

"What I have been saying is that the mode of most of Hawthorne's short stories is that of the daydreams which edge toward nightmare-toward our desire to be pursued, cast out, demolished, damned-daydreams undertaken, I should suppose, so that we may escape the reality of such things and protect ourselves from life. Such daydreams are certainly among the great uses of fiction; for in fiction they become fetishes or amulets, little patron images, more often of devils than saints worn to keep the wind away, which nevertheless blows as it wills and in its own severity. We use them, these fictions, like sympathetic magic or homeopathic medicine, to control our experience of what they represent. It is like sticking wax pins into the wax model of our disaster; and when we put the model away, we put off, having enjoyed it, the disaster." -R.P. Blackmur ("Afterward," The Celestial Railroad and Other Stories by Nathaniel Hawthorne)

Is Hawthorne too dark, too dense, too complex? How many readers today fully appreciate the complex way he probes America's Puritan heritage, its obsession with self and sin? He's a writer who riddles us with more questions than he answers, a kind of blithe court jester standing to the side, challenging our all our assumptions.

Hawthorne's world view is dominated by a position that sets him between America's Puritan past and what (for him) had become its transcendentalist present. We can understand his fiction, especially major works like The Scarlet Letter as his unique attempt to forge some middle ground between the two. We shouldn't overlook, either, the influence of his addiction to popular "penny papers" and crime pamphlets. These cheap, sensational tabloids fascinated Poe and Melville, too. Whatever else we decide about Hawthorne, it's clear that he's an original, which is why he's enjoyed such a lofty place in the literary "canon" for so long.

Here's what Edgar Allen Poe had to say about Hawthorne, in his famous review of Hawthorne's first story collection, Twice-told Tales: "Mr. Hawthorne's distinctive trait is invention, creation, imagination, originality -- a trait which, in the literature of fiction, is positively worth all the rest. But the nature of originality, so far as regards its manifestation in letters, is but imperfectly understood. The inventive or original mind as frequently displays itself in novelty of tone as in novelty of matter. Mr. Hawthorne is original at all points….It would be a matter of some difficulty to designate the best of these tales; we repeat that, without exception, they are beautiful."

What makes Hawthorne popular with readers today?

  • In theme and attitude -- because his vision is filled with irony, ambiguity, and paradox -- his works are still resonant and relevant.
  • He gives us that vivid, unforgettable glimpse into the Puritan psyche, its obsession with sin, its belief in the reality of evil (the devil), and its relentless sense of determinism (the concept of predestination).
  • Pre-Freudian, but post-Shakespearean, the psychology of his characters is complex and still intriguing.
  • For the student of literature, his style and his themes look ahead to major writers like Henry James and William Faulkner (to name just two).


Some of these themes may seem more evident in works other than "The Birthmark," particularly in his masterpiece, The Scarlet Letter, but many of them appear in the "The Birthmark" as well.

ALIENATION: Characters may put themselves in a state of isolation, or they may be forced there by society, or by a combination of both.

INITIATION: Alienated characters may attempt to break out of their isolated condition.

PROBLEM OF GUILT: Characters may feel guilt as a result of their puritanical heritage or as a result of societal pressure. Innocence and guilt may equally plead their case in a Hawthorne story.

PRIDE: In Hawthorne's vision, pride is treated as evil. And pride can be expressed in a variety of forms -- physical, spiritual, or intellectual.

ALLEGORY: Taken in its entirety, Hawthorne's work is thought of as allegorical, even didactic and moralistic, though I would argue that his didacticism and moralizing are complex, not dogmatic, and that his major works, and even "The Birthmark" are morally ambiguous.

OTHERS: Broadly, the themes that concern Hawthorne seem to be the individual vs. society; self-fulfillment vs. accommodation or frustration; hypocrisy vs. integrity, love vs. hate, exploitation vs. hurting; and fate vs. free will.


A major American writer, maybe America's first professional literary artist, Hawthorne's work can be approached from a variety of critical perspectives.

If you were taking a broader historical approach to Hawthorne, you might ask things like:

  • Where did Hawthorne's stories first appear (they were unsigned and low-paid) and which did he choose to collect in Twice-told Tales? How was each book advertised, how well did they sell, how much money did Hawthorne earn from them, and how were they reviewed?
  • What were Hawthorne's career options during and after college, why did he undertake literary hackwork and the writing of children's books?
  • What was the significance of his interludes at Brook Farm, his appointments to the Boston Custom House, the Salem Custom House, and the Liverpool consulate, and of his efforts to win reinstatement at the Salem Custom House?
  • Other historical pursuits: where did Hawthorne stand between Puritan and Whig ideas about the self and the historical past; how did Hawthorne's work refract the political practices and social climate of Jacksonian democracy; and how did Hawthorne's work either reflect or challenge the genteel assumptions of his day concerning the role of women?

If you were taking a biographical approach to Hawthorne, you might ask things like:

  • How did Hawthorne's family history and specific events in his life inform his writings?
  • Does the concern with female "purity" or "perfection" that he explores in "The Birthmark" reflect personal anxieties following his own marriage? How does the scientist's search for perfection relate to the artist's search for beauty?
  • Other biographical issues have to do with the role of his father's death, his experience as a nonconformist college student, and the frustration of his lifelong desire to support himself by writing.

Formalist critics will pursue questions like:

  • How do Hawthorne's "short stories" go beyond previously familiar forms like the sketch or the tale? To what extent is this true of "The Birthmark"?
  • What are the recurrent character types in his works and how do these appear in "The Birthmark"? (Who tend to be his villains or his heroes; who does he seem to criticize, admire, or resign himself to?)
  • What images recur in his work and do these appear in "The Birthmark"? (some critics have noted his use of light vs. dark; natural vs. unnatural; sunshine vs. firelight; labyrinths, etc.
  • What is unique about Hawthorne's open-ended endings and how do you understand the ending of "The Birthmark"?
  • How does he rework his notebooks into polished fiction?

Questions for further studying "The Birthmark"

  1. "The Birthmark" is such a rich story that when we begin to explore its deeper meanings we find ironies, ambiguities, paradoxes, and rich symbols, all of which invite a reader's individual interpretation. What irony, ambiguity, symbol, and paradox do you find most interesting in "The Birthmark"?
  2. In much of his fiction, Hawthorne treats pride as an "evil." Is there an evil type of pride evident in "The Birthmark"?
  3. In what ways is "The Birthmark" for all its promise of an "impressive moral" actually morally ambiguous? Why might some readers find it difficult to view Alymer, for instance, as purely and unambiguously "evil"?
  4. Hawthorne didn't feel himself confined to an aesthetic that privileges "verisimilitude," like many 20th century authors (notable exceptions being Kafka, Borges, and Marquez). He felt comfortable allowing his fiction to include "the spirit and mechanism of the fairyland" (his words). What "fantastic" or "magical" elements appear in "The Birthmark"?
  5. Consider Hawthorne's presentation of Georgiana in "The Birthmark." What attitudes about women seem to inform his portrait of her?
  6. Given that certain themes tend to recur in Hawthorne's fiction, among them the limits of self-reliance and the evils of manipulation, can you analyze how these themes are expressed in "The Birthmark"?

Some Answers....

"The Birthmark" is such a rich story that when we begin to explore its deeper meanings we find ironies, ambiguities, paradoxes, and rich symbols, all of which invite a reader's individual interpretation. What irony, ambiguity, symbol, and paradox do you find most interesting in "The Birthmark"?


According to The Harper Handbook to Literature, "irony is the perception of a clash between appearance and reality, between seems and is, or between ought and is."
Verbal irony involves saying the opposite of what one means. The appearance is what the words say; the reality, their contrary meaning. Both speaker and listener are aware of the contrast, mutually understanding the situation and each other. This silent ironic understanding may flow between author and reader, or between characters within a story, as someone stands by in ignorance, all of which the reader enjoys by listening in.

One minor instance of verbal irony occurs when, having caught her reading in his library, particularly her reading his own folio, Aylmer says to Georgiana "It is dangerous to read in a sorcerer's books." As he says this with a smile, we understand that he is being ironic, and that he considers himself anything but a "sorcerer." It isn't magic or alchemy or wizardry Aylmer is at, but SCIENCE, with its rational propositions and orderly attempts at arriving at truth by minutiae and infinitesimal progressions. Georgiana recognizes the minuscule nature of Aylmer's achievements and feels pity for him, sees in him the same human failure and pathetic imperfection that he sees in her! ("Georgiana, as she read, reverenced Aylmer and loved him more profoundly than ever, but with a less entire dependence on his judgment than heretofore. Much as he had accomplished, she could not but observe that his most splendid successes were almost invariably failures, if compared with the ideal at which he aimed.") The irony doubles when we as readers may believe that they are both wrong in their respective interpretations. Georgiana underestimates Aylmer's accomplishments and considers him a failure-but he isn't considered one; Aylmer thinks Georgiana's birthmark somehow makes her less than human-but she is all too human, vulnerable as any of us to the need for approval. It's possible, however, that we share Georgiana's view by the end of the story-that Aylmer "aims too high"; or we may feel the opposite: that he aims too low-seeking to satisfy his own egotistical desires and not considering his wife's well-being.
Another telling instance of verbal irony in "The Birthmark" is evident when Georgiana dies. Just before she dies, murmuring "Poor Aylmer," Aylmer exclaims, "Poor? Nay, richest, happiest, most favored!….My peerless bride, it is successful! You are perfect!" But she repeats ("with more than human tenderness"), "My poor Aylmer…you have aimed loftily; you have done nobly. Do not repent that with so high and pure a feeling, you have rejected the best the earth could offer." Georgiana insists that her husband has "aimed loftily," has "acted nobly," that his feelings have been "high" and "pure," but the irony (which the astute reader is aware of, though Georgiana, in her innocent trust of appearances is not) is that his aim is anything but lofty. It's his obsessive pride (one of the seven deadly sins), intellectual pride, that has driven him to murder his wife, and for no other reason than that he believed the birthmark to be a mark of evil. He insisted upon his own interpretation of the birthmark as the only valid one; this is intellectual pride.

What was Aylmer's need to create something perfect, to improve upon "the best that nature had to offer"? Did he believe that, as a scientist, that was his role? His pride, however, is what leads him to believe that he, a mere human having made a few minor discoveries (and by his own admission lacking knowledge of the larger mysteries), might be powerful enough to improve upon the Nature's universe as it is. According to Georgiana, Aylmer "spiritualized everything, the merest physical details; the veriest cold of earth assumed a soul." What was Aylmer thinking, then, fiddling with the souls of others? It's hubris-the ancient Greek term for overbearing, excessive pride, the pride that leads to tragedy. Aylmer is arrogant.


Ambiguity refers to a text's ability to communicate more than one meaning. More than one plausible interpretation of character, or conflict, or theme is possible. When a text suggests multiple meanings, it's said to be "ambiguous." William Empson, a noted literary critic, has distinguished seven types of literary ambiguity which "add some nuance to the direct statement of prose": (1) language simultaneously effective in several ways; (2) differing meanings an author finally resolves into one; (3) one word with two apparently unrelated meanings; (4) alternative meanings that illuminate an author's complex feelings; (5) an ambiguous simile, a "fortune confusion," that shows the author discovering an idea; (6) contradictions or irrelevancies that force readers to interpretation; (7) a contradiction revealing an author's ambivalence.
Ambiguity arises in "The Birthmark" when the reader isn't quite sure where to place the blame for Georgiana's death. Is it Aylmer's obsessive striving for perfection that leads him to all but force the deadly draught upon his innocent wife, or is it Georgiana's own imperfect, ironic misunderstanding of her husband's motives that leads her to, for all intents and purposes, commit suicide? Is it her own vanity, her inability to deal with her husband's involuntary "compulsive shudder" that leads her to hate herself so thoroughly that she believes her life isn't worth living? Ultimately, the question of whether her death is murder or suicide is a matter of interpretation. The story is ambiguous; our interpretation depends upon our character analysis of Aylmer and Georgiana, and a thorough investigation of each one's conscious and unconscious motives.

Another instance of ambiguity arises from the symbol of the crimson hand itself. For each character in the story, the hand seems to represent something different. For Aylmer, it represents human imperfection, sin, the "fatal flaw of humanity which nature, in one shape or another, stamps ineffaceably on all her productions, either to imply that they are temporary and finite, or that their perfection must be wrought by toil and pain. The crimson hand expressed the ineludible gripe in which mortality clutches the highest and purest of earthy mold, degrading them into kindred with the lowest, and even with the very brutes, like whom their visible frames return to dust. In this manner, selecting it as the symbol of his wife's liability to sin, sorrow, decay, and death, Aylmer's somber imagination was not long in rendering the birthmark a frightful object, causing him more trouble and horror than ever Georgiana's beauty, whether of soul or sense, had given him delight." For Georgiana, it has been a badge of individuality. When Aylmer asks if she had ever considered having it removed, she responds, "To tell you the truth it has been so often called a charm that I was simple enough to imagine it might be so." Unlike Aylmer or Georgiana, or her former lovers, the servant Aminadab finds it funny that his master should wish to remove the birthmark, and he goes so far as to laugh when Georgiana expires as a result of the "operation." Clearly, it represents something different to him than to either of the other characters. To the reader, the "hand" may represent a different kind of "imperfection"-a purely physical one; unlike Aylmer, the reader may not feel the need to connect it to "spiritual" imperfection.


A paradox is a statement which seems on its face to be self-contradictory or absurd yet turns out to make good sense.
Perhaps it is a paradox when Georgiana refers to her "fatal birthmark." On the surface, the birthmark is by no means fatal. It has been merely a curiosity, a minor flaw on an otherwise "unblemished" face. To call a simple cosmetic peculiarity "fatal" seems contradictory. Paradoxically, however, because of what it comes to represent to both she and her husband, the birthmark does become fatal. The birthmark in an of itself is not fatal, but because of the way it is interpreted, it becomes fatal. Its removal causes her death. This reminds me somewhat of anorexia. The misinterpreted body image-the distortion of the physical image-has fatal consequences. Whose distortion is responsible? Like Aylmer and Georgiana, it takes the two of them to produce the result; there's a little bit of murder and a little bit of suicide all ambiguously mixed together.

A phrase of Georgiana's also seems paradoxical: "Either remove this dreadful hand, or take my wretched life! You have deep science…" [my italics] This must have been a striking phrase to nineteenth century ears. Even to us today, it may seem contradictory; what is actually "deep" about science, which concerns itself with the physical nature-the surface-of things; science doesn't attempt to answer the kind of "deep" psychological, philosophical, or spiritual questions that continually puzzle us. (Michael Behe may observe "irreducible complexity" but as a scientist, he doesn't attempt to pinpoint the exact philosophical ramifications of such a discovery. He leaves that to the theologians, the philosophers.) Science can't cure human fallibility or eradicate sin, original or otherwise. So, on the surface, Georgiana seems to introduce a contradiction by using this strange phrase. But if we delve deeper, perhaps it makes sense. In Aylmer's view, science is a means to tap into that "secret of creative force and perhaps make [a] new [world] for himself." Aylmer's faith in science does reach the depths: he sees it as the pathway to our "ultimate control over Nature." If science can cure imperfection (physical or otherwise), removing the hideous mark of sin from our earthly flesh, then perhaps his is a "deep science." Or perhaps this is an unforgivable delusion, a delusion which leads him to inflict undue suffering and an untimely death upon his innocent wife.

The last sentences of the story, if you can crack them, seem to suggest paradoxical insights: "Yet, had Aylmer reached a profounder wisdom, he need not thus have flung away the happiness which would have woven his mortal life of the selfsame texture with the celestial. The momentary circumstance was too strong for him; he failed to look beyond the shadowy scope of time, and living once for all in eternity, to find the perfect future in the present." The phrase "perfect future in the present" seems paradoxical, contradictory. His horror of imperfection (the imperfect present) overpowered his reason-he sacrificed all earthly happiness chasing after perfection where it cannot be found. He failed to take the long view; perfection only exists in eternity, which belongs to God, not humans. Our only perfect future is our present. This is almost like a zen koan, defying rational explanation!


The textbook defines a symbol as any person, object, image, word, or event that evokes a range of additional meaning beyond and usually more abstract than its literal significance. Symbols evoke complex ideas without explicitly explaining them; they work well in fiction because (unlike the essay) it is a mode more experiential than reflective. Conventional symbols (or "public" symbols, as they are sometimes called) have universal meanings easily recognized, especially within the culture the writer shares. As your textbook explains, "spring" functions symbolically, for instance, in "The Story of An Hour," evoking the fresh start Mrs. Mallard experiences when confronted with the death of her husband. Contextual (or "private" symbols) are meaningful only within the context of the work they appear in (Sammy's "I quit" as a heroic gesture).
In "The Birthmark," the most prominent, obvious symbol is the birthmark itself. For Aylmer, the birthmark symbolizes mortality, decay, sin, and imperfection. This view of his wife's cheek causes him obsessive unease, which finally leads him to kill her. A feminist might view the birthmark as a symbol of the male's inability to accept the "real" female on equal terms, preferring instead the inhuman ideal-he would prefer her to be the object of perfection, an idol he can worship. This nullifies her actual humanity.

In much of his fiction, Hawthorne treats pride as an "evil." Is there an evil type of pride evident in "The Birthmark"?

Perhaps Hawthorne had a specific kind of Christian "evil" in mind, but I think it's possible to define "evil" apart from any specific theological definitions, and consider it as an ethical or existential problem. If that which is evil is that which distinctly and defiantly operates against the good, then Aylmer's insistence on removing his wife's harmless birthmark at the cost of her life and for his own selfish pleasure seems decidedly evil. If you believe that human life is a sacred, self-evident, and inalienable good, not to be disposed of needlessly, then it seems that Aylmer's intellectual pride, which leads him to believe he can "correct what Nature left imperfect in her fairest work," a belief which causes him to poison his wife and cause her death, is, indeed, evil.
Aylmer's whole reaction to his wife's birthmark proves his egotism, which leads to the "surprising consequences" promised in the beginning of the story, and the deeply impressive moral (egotism can be evil). He believes that his way of seeing it-his own egotistical interpretation-is the only possible one and never strives, for his wife's sake, to see the birthmark as anything but as a symbol of imperfection-of sin, decay, death. He doesn't stop to consider whether this is fair to his wife, or hurtful to her. When it is hurtful (she becomes suicidal on his account), he merely praises her for her "noble, lofty soul." His incapacity to see outside his own selfish concerns, because of the consequences it engenders, might very well be considered "evil" or at the very least "morally outrageous"! Psychologically stunted, egotistical, conceited, immoral-all of these tags seem to apply to the Aylmer who would kill his wife rather than face her birthmark.

In what ways is "The Birthmark" for all its promise of an "impressive moral" actually morally ambiguous? Why might some readers find it difficult to view Alymer, for instance, as purely and unambiguously "evil"?

Ambiguity, as has already been discussed, involves the possibility of alternate interpretations. If we agree that the story is a moral tale, even an allegory demonstrating this impressive moral (demonstrating, for instance, that "egotism is evil") then we might be inclined to say that the story is not ambiguous in this sense. It demonstrates a moral and the truth of that moral is the only interpretation possible. The question, then, is whether the story is more than straight allegory, whether more than one interpretation is possible.
I believe the story is morally ambiguous because we aren't quite sure where to place the blame for Georgiana's death. Is it science itself, Aylmer's egotism, or Georgiana's vanity? If we put the blame on science itself, then it is human nature itself that is responsible for this death-the human pursuit of knowledge, perfection-it sounds like original sin. The grasping after scientific knowledge, the attempt to master the "secret of creative force and perhaps make new worlds" represents Adam's biting into the forbidden fruit, and the "surprising consequences" follow. Aylmer is just the latest representative in a long chain of original sinners trying to partake of this forbidden meal. If we fault Aylmer himself, then it isn't human nature in general to blame, but Aylmer's own individual egotism which blinds him to the evil he's perpetrating. However, if we ascribe some of the blame to Georgiana herself, the problem becomes even more complex. Now, Aylmer is partly to blame, but Georgiana has her part as well. Why can't she shrug off the vision of her husband's convulsive shudder? Is her vanity so strong that she becomes unable to withstand his disapproval? Why is she so dependent on his approval in the first place? Her weakness is not only psychological, but moral when you consider that suicide is morally sinful. So who is morally responsible for this death? The answer is ambiguous.

Hawthorne didn't feel himself confined to an aesthetic that privileges "verisimilitude," like many 20th century authors (notable exceptions being Kafka, Borges, and Marquez). He felt comfortable allowing his fiction to include "the spirit and mechanism of the fairyland" (his words). What "fantastic" or "magical" elements appear in "The Birthmark"?

The fantastic element in "The Birthmark" is perhaps not as evident as in some of Hawthorne's other stories. We might be tempted to see Aylmer, in his laboratory, as the sorcerer he ironically names himself to be, but his wizardry is vastly understated. First, we have the weird flower, which magically blooms before their eyes. It withers to black at Georgiana's touch. Aylmer looks on thoughtfully. "Too powerful a stimulus," he decides. Is there such a flower in real life? If so, I've never heard of it! But this powerful "sorcerer" seems to possess secrets beyond our ken. Next he attempts to take a picture of Georgiana (why, I'm not sure) but it comes out blurry-only the birthmark is distinct. This has a touch of the ghostly to it, but maybe he just shook his camera a bit, being so nervous, causing the image to blur, and because he's so fixated on the birthmark, he still sees it there, despite the blurriness. Next, he brags of an elixir capable of extending life, then of a potion composed of an essence capable of impregnating all the air-he sprinkles some in the lab as a demonstration. He shows her another potion that removes freckles; but insists that it is merely superficial and that her case will require something far "deeper." Our scientist never seems more the quack than during these episodes. It would be interesting to know how Hawthorne's audience received these descriptions, whether they deemed Aylmer mad or not.

Further web study

Nathaniel Hawthorne Page at bartleby.com

Hawthorne and the Craft of the Short Story

Hawthorne's Women






Questions? Contact me.

All materials unless otherwise indicated are copyright © 2001-2002 by Stacy Tartar Esch.
FALL 2001 site is available at BRAINSTORM-SERVICES.COM
The original contents of this site may not be reproduced, republished, reused, or retransmitted
without the express written consent of Stacy Tartar Esch.
These contents are for educational purposes only.