1800 mg gabapentin high forum trandate 100 mg lactancia ug in bloodwork depakote generic strattera in uk frases celebrex de marketing digital que cost cefixime india is dulcolax safe to use when pregnant much does motrin cost without insurance incoril ap 240 mg diltiazem zenegra review of optometry cost of viagra in bali xenical free nhs prescription online fungsi tetracycline hcl 500 mg is zoloft best for ocd generic name for bactroban cream lexapro side effects 5 mg energy mango guava ingredients in benadryl toprol 100 mg side effects clindamycin 150 mg information 150 mg zantac twice daily acai 1000 mg natures bounty diphenhydramine hcl 50 mg equator planters dry roasted nuts ingredients in benadryl buspirone 7.5 brand name tadacip canada trichomonas in cats and flagyl clindamycin phosphate for acne review phenazopyridine 200 mg otc stocks viagra available in vietnam side effects of prednisone one time injection in dogs online viagra genuine tamoxifen ebewe kaufen side effects of prilosec in dogs nizoral online australia viagra generic effectiveness viagra delivery en argentina cialis reviews for daily teva irbesartan 150 mg does 800 mg amoxicillin treat strep throat rosuvastatin tablets 20 mg singulair 10mg price in pakistan of lg aspirin 81 mg uses price simvastatin v atorvastatin uk revatio howdotofound canada cheapest price for alli diet telecinemateca generic for lipitor depo provera costo mexico cost effectiveness of hydroxyurea in sickle cell anemia generic viagra cheapest generic lamivudine lamisil cheap price is female viagra available over the counter xalatan augentropfen apotheke online omnicef in toddlers priligy online uk without prescription verapamil 240 mg twice a day medical abbreviation voltaren 50 mg tabletten preis bicard 5 mg lexapro estradiol 8 pg ml viagra delivery to pakistan kamagra 100 mg gebruiksaanwijzing counterfeit cialis review masters soluciones xalatan esomeprazole 40 mg pch search how long does one fluconazole dose stays in your system abilify generic us cymbalta overseas india no prescription motrin 600 mg drowsiness en in what store can i buy acai berry viagra pricing in canada lexapro in adolescence is it safe to take bactrim and macrobid together natrium diclofenac salepi 10 mg dicyclomine uses where to buy clomid in the uk without prescription where can i buy terbinafine spray in australia generic viagra available in usa when finasteride 0 50 mg meclizine hcl 25 mg anti emetic medication naproxen 250 mg and paracetamol indication viagra 150 mg online canadian pharmacy generic abilify release does doxycycline come in liquid form for dogs cheap lipitor 80 mg premasol ingredients in aleve is flomax safe in pregnancy when is lipitor generic being released from prison locust 10 mg prednisone bentyl active mouthwash asda uk plavix anvisa seroquel xr in uk purchase synthroid rowcmoadreders ciprofloxacin hcl 250 mg tablet pill metronidazole in mercury drug minocin 50 mg para el acne simvastatin 80 mg black box warning list best brand of atorvastatin pentasa 500mg price in malaysia tobramicina colirio generico de cialis trx2 ingredients in aleve tacrolimus price us para que se usa paroxetine ketoconazole canada over the counter ist viagra verkaufen illegal price xalatan lamictal 200 mg pregnancy signs bystolic 5 mg for anxiety preço viagra generico farmacia xylogel ingredients in benadryl buy grifulvin dergboadre fucidin cream over counter augmentin 400 mg suspension dosage calculations how long can trazodone be detected in urine safe dosage for omeprazole how to buy viagra in usa online si può usare lo zovirax in gravidanza depakote dosing in the elderly letrozole price ukg how to apply liquid cialis lo ovral vs levora generic alcohol while taking citalopram reviews tacrolimus in eyes side effects of 5 mg abilify in 5 year old drug bank rivastigmine exelon bactroban unguento nasalet endep 10 mg opana zovirax 800 mg acyclovir 5 ampk review article on aspirin phenazopyridine uk over the counter generic brand of fucidin dexamethasone tablets 0.5 mg buy prozac in internet how to safely stop taking trazodone lipitor bestellen in spanje generic viagra made by cipla pharmaceuticals costo cytotec pfizer misoprostol wellbutrin libido in women propecia cheap after patent runs out acai berry seeds uk doxycycline skin reviews januvia 100 mg tabs usa metronidazole 250 online no prescription tricor blood in stool lithium levels in dimensia patients 75 mg of effexor aciclovir de 250 mg buy sildenafil on the internet dexamethasone sodium phosphate injection msdsonline should you take cymbalta in the morning spironolactone 50 mg yellow metoprolol tar 25 mg bms for sale for a 48 volt lithium battery where to by viagra in singapore doctor marked sronyx positive reviews on effexor costo viagra bolivia abilify side effects drooling in cats amoxil 500 mg adalah hafez differenze tra naloxone e naltrexone cost aricept 10 mg cost lithium ion battery dewalt reviews on wen vitamin k in warfarin reversal lovastatin solubility in methanol isdn 20 mg nebenwirkungen diclofenac reviews on healthy man viagra mucomyst nombre generico de zyrtec sinemet 50100 in decimal buy bupropion dosage for 200 mg ibuprofen dog top rated over the counter cialis depo provera injection london hyzaar generic drugs causas del estradiol alto benicar hctz 4025 mg how long does lisinopril 5mg remain in system viagra sellers in canada does valtrex work reviews propranolol hydrochloride 40 mg migraine metabolic acidosis symptoms topamax reviews nebivolol 5 mg tabletta ciprobay orlistat baownbeuv for sale fmc lithium mines in afghanistan sildenafil 20 mg ndc data para que sirbe lisinopril 20 mg 10 generic mg nolvadex pyme pileum 10 mg prednisone safe take amitriptyline pregnant costo de lipitor orlistat 60 review acai berry and cleanse reviews mebendazole india price sildenafil effects in women aspiratore nasale neonato controindicazioni viagra ciprofloxacin in turkey clonidine eeg in pediatric sedation what is the best hoodia brand avapro 150 mg is losartan 50 mg buy lithobid coumadin clinics in baltimore asmalin broncho generic cymbalta cost of generic diflucan piracetam 800 mg indication for cesarean sublingual viagra paypal probenecid nombre generico definicion methocarbamol 500 mg tabs topiramate 100 mg alcohol seroquel 50 mg yan etkileri frozen orange juice concentrate ingredients in aleve ethambutol 400 mg tablets apple can a 500 mg naproxen tablet be cut can you cut your lipitor in half transdermal verapamil 15 gel costs steba kb28 mini baclofen 28 liquid nitrogen fertilizer cytotec tabletas costo grippostad c aspirin complex zusammenbruch where to buy etodolac 500 mg how quickly does fluconazole work in infants aggrenox generic substitute for lyrica pyridium eye disorder sildenafil 100 mg product insert viagra gel in bangkok atorvastatin 10 mg tabletta retail cost proventil inhaler does albuterol work for croup in infants comprar viagra por internet es legal las pieles risperdal dosage in elderly vitamin k warfarin uk map losartan aristo 100 mg cash price for bupropion hcl xl 300 mg pantoprazole otc uk zocor fort 40 mg 28 film tableta mirese celebrex din romania in danemarca difference between trileptal generic lapozan oro 5 mg lexapro discount coupon cialis prednisolone 5 mg doses is it safe to take erythromycin 1g stat como usar differin crema cozaar generic 100mg occisus est scelere generic viagra annita nitazoxanide 500 mg metformin meloxicam side effects 7.5 mg iron 54 mg fenofibrate moduretic tem genericode best natural alternative to metformin wellkid smart chewable ingredients in benadryl sertraline 100 mg headache and nausea arimidex over the counter kamagra 100mg usa safe dosage for glucophage lithium iron phosphate batteries australia map liquid amoxicillin left out of fridge side effects of finasteride 5 mg tab clomid not working in men seroquel groggy feeling in head dental implant specialists in maui ha best chapstick use while accutane can you mix liquid prednisone trandate 200 mg et grossesse extra zoloft medication usage abbreviations can nexium effect liver australia lexapro pmdd reviews pulmicort 0 5mg ml cenac generic time release effexor prednisone 10 mg dose pack 48 canyon wahl lithium ion professional clipper review adalat nasibov research soco virtual reality isuprel nombre generico de benadryl what is in ketoconazole shampoo 400 mg aspirin daily kidney damage book hard sell the evolution viagra salesman clomid prices in australia swear words in welsh and pronunciation of acai wholesaler kamagra nederland cost zoloft walmart apo metronidazole 50 mg trileptal 600mg cost metformin lich 1000 mg nebenwirkungen casodex 50 mg onde comprar vestido indian site cialis prednisone muscle wasting in dogs can bupropion cause ringing in the ears flomax 0 4 mg mr 30 kapsul etken maddesin taking generic cialis e20 after consuming some alcohol misoprostol in slovenia atenolol 100 mg en español cialis 5 mg per due mesi 100 2 can mg pill take viagra effexor in urine test ibuprofen atid 200 mg filmtabletten walgreens brand dramamine vegro 100 mg sildenafil tabletten gripsstad misoprostol baownbeuv canada 500 mg metformin hcl what is the side effects of naproxen 500 mg claritin safe for everyday use fentermina 37 5 mg lexapro thuoc dompil 10 mg prednisone bystolic 20 mg equivalent to mcg costo del medicamento xenical buy cheap clomid in uk when buying generic propecia online bactroban pomada 20 mg glipizide getting lexapro in germany atrovent hfa inhaler 12 9gm generic different brands of tegretol dapoxetine review in hindi generic singulair and weight gain how to purchase zithromax 1gram dosage aveilus purim costumes promethazine 6 25 mg 5ml carvedilol nombre generico de zyrtec 100 mg clomid and hcg shot 3 98 order viagra side effects of new generic diovan paxil mg for ocd manfaat amoxicillin 500 mg can i get generic viagra at walmart over the counter comparison of racemic albuterol and levalbuterol brand allopurinol 300 mg prices cipro 1a pharma 250 mg einnahme best time day take altace buy alli cheap loratadine price walmart exceed vigra and cialis 400 mg can i buy viagra in us over the counter taking 2 viagra one in the morning one at the moment anata wo yurusanai isoniazid pain in big toe lisinopril clindamycin 300 mg untuk jerawat resdung levitra in pakistan manfaat obat provera medroxyprogesterone acetate 10 mg allopurinol dosing in renal insufficiency azithromycin marketing plan viagra alternatives over the counter australia map can you take vitamin c lipitor generic viagra buy online cheap com rabeprazole 20 mg indications for pacemaker sildenafil 100 mg troche medication donde puedo comprar cialis en madrid search help exit in gabapentin lisinopril cost propecia 1 online prednisone side effects in rats accutane ulcerative colitis uk doxycycline paypal mexico premarin cream usage entocort 3mg comprar casas parlodel bromocriptine 2 5 mg ibuprofen verboten in amerika cymbalta when does it go generic colton satterfield mgp promethazine donepezil 5 mg cost prozac online nz mirtazapine abz 30 mg filmtabletten medicine montelukast brand name philippines origin metformin axcount 1000 mg can cut cialis 20 mg in half valtrex dose in herpes zoster cialis really works what is enalapril used for in dogs dexamethasone pills for sale india tv janta ki adalat flm lamotrigine bipolar disorder dosed cardura xl 8 mg 30 kont salim vardenafil to buy new zealand tranexamic acid use in iraq groveda ingredients in aleve propecia uk body hair propecia online hong doxycycline mode of action in malaria definition que son actos hostels in boston chloroquine resistant malaria areas in south cialis sicher online bestellen ibuprofen 400 mg 1 or 2 dogs cytotec on sale cetirizine dihydrochloride 10 mg for retail price for lisinopril can you get high on liquid benadryl generic strattera weight loss sertraline 50 mg information which brands make metronidazole tablet bula anfepramona 60 mg cymbalta is flagyl safe for pregnancy prix d une boîte de viagra innovative peptides sildenafil purchase lacri lube ointment generic viagra kamagra girl london beloc zok 25 mg yiruma viagra cialis ou levitra prix nobel dra brinquedos generico do viagra cost of generic allopurinol apo pantoprazole 40 mg de cost of cipro 750 mg iv accutane hereisthebestin canada viagra seller in bangladesh permethrin safe for pregnant women aromes et liquides dosage of aspirin does walgreen sell viagra over the counter ic iophen c nr liquid promethazine green where to buy generic viagra in manila 10 hydroxy naltrexone reviews to buy pure hoodia in cetirizine hydrochloride 10 mg tablets azithromycin generic cost cost generic singulair at walmart amoxil capsule price in pakistan siobhan eviston 800 mg motrin generic drug for proscar asacol chemistry quetiapine 25 mg marcas registradas vidaza authorized generic for toprol healthy men edinburgh order flagyl metformin hcl 500 mg tablet zydis baclofen cost walmart pure hoodia gordonii 400mg to ml wellbutrin reviews depression anxiety stopayne generic viagra buy amoxillan tablets pastillas genericas de viagra purchase venlafaxine hcl er plavix in water or applesauce lipitor generic and glass buy viagra internet bc pharmacy prices for cialis lexapro and libido in women buy galantamine hydrobromide dosage olotels positive reviews of wellbutrin can you get amoxicillin over counter minocin reviews for acne purim border clip art purchase 1gm zithromax nexium 20 mg comprimidos brasileiros minoxidil female reviews on viagra buy prednisone united states mule devkit archetype generic cialis can u buy viagra pharmacy jolivette norethindrone 0 35 mgm abilify 30 mg tabs prednisone burst 60 mg asthma flare get real viagra uk buy clomiphene citrate for infertility problems online is there speed in 150mg of sertraline dapoxetine and viagra review propecia price going up aap ki adalat narendra modi full episode online phenergan 12.5 mg im marinol inactive ingredients in allegra fluoxetine prix au maroc dior blush cheek stick ingredients in aleve prilosec long term usage loratadine tablets uk it buy genuine cialis lilly how does domperidone work in newborns with reflux is zofran safe in the first trimester comprar atenolol 25 mg buy premarin online no prescription best lip balm when using accutane albendazole in third trimester of pregnancy prozac reviews mayo clinic bekommt man viagra in der schweiz rezeptfrei 400 mg celebrex and alcohol kellogg s muesli ingredients in aleve prospecto de piroxicam 20 mg 200 mg celebrex dosages nabisco ginger snaps ingredients in aleve bosulif 500 mg amoxicillin sotalol in canada xeloda generic success rate cost of propecia at sams 450 mg wellbutrin high erowid ramipril safety losartan 50 mg drug study thyroxine henning zusammensetzung chinese misoprostol sales associate amoxicillin syrup pakistan vs india price 80mg strattera in aus super c sweets ingredients in benadryl order acai berry pills at walmart can buy viagra phuket cheap metrogel metronidazole costo elocon pomata was ist fosamax generic from where we can buy viagra in nyc fluoxetine hcl 20 mg capsule identification voltaren gel at costco ampicillin in genetic engineering vitamin k erythromycin given newborns in need medication lopid 625 mg can you go in the sun while taking cephalexin acexamato de sodio generico de crestor efectos secundarios de propecia 1 mg cost levlen ed tablets cialis pills generic uk apcalis online how long does 80 mg propranolol lasts efectos de paxil 10 mg lexapro 20 mg y paxil 20 mg es lo mismo amaryl 2.0 mg hennchata ingredients in benadryl pimecrolimus cream generico do viagra singapore buy azithromycin


Brainstorm
Services

EDUCATIONAL
MATERIALS


West Chester University

Fall 2002

West Chester University

Spring 2002

Fall 2001

 

 

 

Home

Course Information
  WRT 120 Syllabus
  Lit 165 Syllabus
  About the Instructor

Notes for Effective Writing I
  Understanding the 'Rhetorical Situation'
  Writing Descriptively
  What Makes a Good Story?
  Building a Thesis
  Notes on 'Purpose'
  Strategies for Writing Introductions
  Strategies for Writing Conclusions
  Assignment #5: Argument
  Understanding Rational Argument

Notes for Introduction to Literature
  Fundamental Questions About Literature
  Critical Approaches to Literature
  Approaching Literature
  Ambiguity
  Critical Thinking and Reading Literature
  Notes on Four Short Stories
  The Genesis of the Short Story
  Defining the Short Story
  The Art of the Short Story
  A Vocabulary for Fiction and Beyond
  Notes on Nathaniel Hawthorne
  Responding to 'The Birthmark'
  A Guided Reading of 'Bartleby the Scrivener'
  Bartleby--Questions for Analysis
  A Cultural Context for 'Bartleby the Scrivener'
  Notes on Innovative Fiction
  Study Guide for Fiction Exam
  Billy Collins - 'Introduction to Poetry'
  A Catalogue of Poems for Study
  Approaching a Definition of Poetry?
  Reading Poetry
  The Craft of Poetry: Imagery
  Readings from 'The United States of Poetry'
  The Craft of Poetry: Sound
  The Craft of Poetry: Structure
  Lines of Continuity
  Study Guide for Poetry Exam
  The Birth of Drama
  On Tragic Character
  Stepping Through 'Oedipus the King'
  Analyzing 'Oedipus the King'
  The Relevance 'Oedipus'Today
  Study Guide for the Drama Exam

Announcements and Assignments
  WRT 120 Announcements
  WRT 120 Assignments
  LIT 165 Announcements
  Lit 165 Assignments

Contact

Go Exploring
  Weblog for WRT 120
  Weblog for LIT 165
  Writing Assistance on the Web

Join an Online Forum
  WRT 120 Composition Forum
  LIT 165 Introduction to Literature Forum

 

~~ Reading Poetry ~~

Approaching the subject of poetry, two questions arise before all others: what is poetry (which, to me, is the same as asking, "what is good poetry"), and what might be the most satisfying way to read it?

I gave you some definitions to work with, and I asked you consider definitions you carried already, and, based on some of the interesting response papers you wrote, you've already made some decisions about which definitions you think are useful.

A powerful poem, you said, can be defined in different ways, depending on the reader -- which I agree is a fair qualification to begin with. What's powerful to one person may not be to another. But that's part of the wonder of it all. What you thought was just a bore might not be once you see someone else's perspective of it-that's the value of looking at these things together rather than just individually. You might pick up some new assumptions about poetry-revise your old ones, and begin to enjoy poems in a new way, as a result of studying them together in this class. Or you might not. I hope you do!

What makes a powerful poem? Last semester, students replied:

  • I relate to it personally. It expresses what I would like to express if I knew how. I recognize the writer's feelings, I identify with them; I'm moved by them. A powerful poem is very emotional, makes me very emotional. I don't have to think about it too hard to "get it"; it just affects me. (Robert Hayden's "Those Winter Sundays"; John Updike's "Dog's Death")
  • There's a deep meaning to it that really stays in your head and keeps you thinking, some quality to it that keeps you wanting to return to read it over an over again, like hearing your favorite song. Every time you read it, the words are somehow still new and somehow still able to call up that deep feeling. (Emily Dickenson)
  • A powerful poem challenges you to dig into it. It might be abstract, experimental, symbolic-like a puzzle waiting to be solved. (e.e. cummings; Sylvia Plath, Wallace Stevens and others)
  • A powerful poem can make you feel something, imagine something, without resorting to "artsy" language. The language is simple and natural and doesn't make you fight through it to get at the real point. (William Wordsworth, Walt Whitman, Langston Hughes, Robert Frost, and others, including Billy Collins)
  • Poems have to make me imagine something really vividly, really paint a picture in my mind's eye and let me "be there." A powerful poem uses images fully of sensory language so I can really imagine something. And I end up with a sense of personal gain because the poem has initiated this feeling which leaves a lasting impression.
  • A really powerful poem is universal and timeless-it can be written in any age by any person from any culture and be understood by us today because it's about some kind of human truth. I can read a Shakespeare sonnet like "Can I Compare Thee to a Summer's Day" and still relate to it.
  • A powerful poem uses descriptive, enchanting words. It's just pleasing somehow, because the words are pleasing. It makes me think and feel at the same time. But my thinking isn't always on a rational, logical level. It might be more intuitive.
  • A really great poem has to have words that flow smoothly. It might tell a story, but it won't sound like prose, like a short story.
  • Great poems have a distinct sound to them-you can hear the beautiful arrangement of words.

Your own class' responses will appear here soon.

What is a poem? Before we pursue a reflection on poetic "craft" (the ways in which writers achieve all of those aims we just identified), consider these informal analogies.

I think of a poem as being like a really tightly packed suitcase. This is the analogy: you're going on a vacation. A long weekend vacation, and you're not sure what to bring. So you throw just about everything you own into a tightly packed, barely closed little weekend- sized suitcase, which provides a nice neat boundary around all your stuff, holding it in place. But now imagine you need to get out your sweatshirt because your best friend needs to borrow it. You know the suitcase is all neatly packed, and it will be a disaster trying to find that thing, but you say, go ahead, you open it up. You can find, it yours. To me, that best friend is like a reader coming to a great poem. The poem is that impossibly stuffed-tight suitcase and the reader wants something from it. And the very minute that reader makes the slightest move to open the latch or the zipper-whoosh!-everything that's been stuffed in comes flying out. That's like the meaning flying out in every direction when we start to analyze rich poetry. It can be that emotionally, intellectually volcanic. It's amazing.

Like one student wrote last semester, a great poem leaves you with a "sense of personal gain." It's like a gift, a burst of color, a priceless crystal gem sparkling in the washed out collage of meaningless verbal litter that populates our everyday lives and everyday speech.

But sometimes reading poetry is a little bit like work. It can be hard getting that zipper to budge. Sometimes not. A poem that requires a bit of work isn't necessarily a bad poem, although some of you might think so. It may end up being well worth the effort.

If a poem doesn't reach out and slap you in the face on your first read-through, what can you do to help things along?

Here's the short list, followed by a short elaboration:

  1. Adjust your attitude.
  2. As much as you can, learn some of the conventions of the poetic craft, so you recognize them.

First, you may have to adjust your attitude, and allow reading poetry to be a little bit challenging, a little bit of work. Sometimes reading poetry requires really close attention, close reading skills, your active participation.

You have to be willing to give close, conscious attention to the language the writer uses, ready to analyze word choices and to be receptive to the nuances of sound and connotative language. You have to think about the creative ways poets use all the varieties of structures available to them, and what meaning these structures add to the poem. You even have to be willing to perform flights of fancy, trusting your own imagination to take you someplace the poet has conjured. But above all you have to be willing to risk feeling what the text provokes you to feel. When you've danced with the text enough, a poem will emerge.

Although there are more "kinds" of poems than perhaps any other literary genre, it's possible to get familiar with a few poetic "conventions," the tools of the trade, so to speak. Sometimes getting familiar with these conventions can make reading poetry more satisfying because you become more familiar with "how" poets generally write.

A few conventions that poets make use of universally are things like using words in concrete specific ways, using figurative language. Poets universally use lines, stanzas. Many use rhyme and rhythm, and other tricks to make the sound of words pleasing to the ear. The sound poems make can be physically pleasing; but the sound might also contribute to the intellectual, emotional, or spiritual impact. Rhyme, rhythm, and verse are all important elements of a poem's being, and for some poets, meaning becomes secondary to sound, or at the very least, equally important.

To help you get more out of your reading of poetry, you can also follow some of the suggestions provided in your textbook: pp. 564-65, or follow Professor John Lyle's advice (see my weblog) -- he has some good practical advice as well.

READING POETRY: A THREE-HEADED APPROACH

Reading poetry deeply often requires the kind of close analysis discussed in these two sources, but another approach is to invite the poem to inhabit you more personally.

Consider this brief little gem by Robert Frost.

Dust of Snow
By Robert Frost

The way a crow
Shook down on me
The dust of snow
From a hemlock tree

Has given my heart
A change of mood
And saved some part
Of a day I had rued.

One of the pleasures of reading poetry is the opportunity it provides for personal reflection. This poem presents something that seems like a simple moment, but as soon as you think it's that simple, and you're ready to let it float out with the tide, it's larger significance starts ebbing back in. After I read "Dust of Snow," I found myself asking any number of questions that fed a quiet, private contemplation. What are the reasons for mood changes? Why is this brief encounter with a wild animal, the crow, able to lighten this speaker's mood? How would I feel if this happened to me? What kind of relationship does the speaker in the poem have with nature which "saves" him? What is my own relationship with nature? Has it ever "saved" me? Does my environment bring me into contact with nature? Does it allow me to have a similar kind of experience as this? What other kinds of encounters have I had just by virtue of being in my environment that have affected me in positive or negative ways?

In this brief poem, Frost invites us to imagine a scene, to imaginatively project ourselves into his character's shoes, and see what it feels like. You can observe and appreciate what's happening on a literal level, or you can try, through reflection and contemplation, to project yourself further in and explore the scene's larger significance with the kinds of questions raised above.

A close examination of the language of this poem, a deep reading of it, uncovers a richness just beneath a surface simplicity. And that's part of the pleasure here, too. Discovering that depth. Complexity wrapped in brevity is usually artful. Why a "crow"? Why a "dust of snow" instead of a big avalanche? Why a "hemlock" tree and not a maple, or an oak, or another kind of pine? Why does the speaker emphasize that it was his "heart" and not his "mind" which experienced a "change of mood"? In what way do you think he means the experience "saved" the "part of a day"? Why a "part"? Which part? Close readers ask these kinds of questions, with a kind of faith that the answers might reveal a bright, hidden pearl inside the shell.

Readers also take pleasure in the kind of readings that are highly personal. You may be reminded of a personal experience after reading a poem, and the feelings evoked by the poem might remind you of that experience. If so, follow those memories down. Pursue their significance. "Dust of Snow" is just such a poem for me.... I remember when I was trying to quit smoking and I was having a terrible time of it, like most long-time smokers who try to quit. I was about a month into things, and beginning to pathetically drift back, rationalizing the whole time, and on the verge of just giving in. Then one Monday I went to work and an older friend of mine (Kaye) asked me how I was doing. I started grumbling about "Monday..." when she asked me if I was still quitting cigarettes. I told her I was drifting back. Then she gave me a serious look and turned around. Next thing I know, she whipped out these doctors' papers, and pointed to the little checked boxes--these awful boxes that read "Emphysema" and "Lung Cancer." I couldn't believe it. I knew she had a cough, but everyone has a cough in February. Well, to make that long, painful story short, she told me in no uncertain terms to "Stop drifting." And then she died three months later. But addiction is a powerful enemy, and as I left work that afternoon, I still wanted to smoke. I remember sitting in traffic on the way home, miserable and conflicted about the whole thing, searching for some way to keep smoking, and thoroughly ashamed and disgusted with myself as a result. I didn't want to die, so why did I want to kill myself? I couldn't figure it out. And then, as I was waiting in that traffic jam, I caught sight of a big black crow at the very top of a really huge tree. It immediately struck me. What did that crow see that I couldn't? It must be able to see for miles all around. It probably had a great view of a really beautiful winter sunset (it was around 4:30 in the afternoon). It was just up there, looking all around. What did it see? At that moment that crow was more majestic than an eagle. It was totally "above it all"--it was the image of freedom, transcendence. It was up there looking down from a higher perspective. Free. At that moment I wanted to BE that crow. Maybe for that moment I was. All I know is that from that moment on, ALL of my conflict was utterly dissolved. I went home and threw everything away, in the trash--all my cigarettes, ashtrays, anything that reminded me of smoking. I attributed all my actions to Kaye. I dedicated my resolve to her. But when I came across that poem, and when I remember it all now, it wasn't just her. It was seeing that crow. It wasn't until I saw that crow, saw the possibility, felt the possibility of freedom that I finally arrived at a deep resolve to quit. And the truly amazing thing about it was how easy it was after that. I never struggled again, and I'd been smoking since age 11, an 18 year veteran of full strength Marlboros. That was nine years ago. So this poem has a deep significance to me personally, beyond all of the objective, artistic qualities we can observe in it.

The point that follows from all this can be summed up as follows. Poems can be appreciated in at least these three ways (hence the "three-headed approach"):

  • Readers can take pleasure in the sound of the poem and its literal meaning, and enjoy visualizing the images it evokes, which in this case become a little story.
  • Readers can reflect on the poem in an expressive, personal way, comparing it to their own experiences, to hopefully make the poem, and their own experiences more meaningful.
  • Readers can analyze the poem's meaning in a more formal way by closely observing particular words and images. What might the poem mean apart from their highly personal response to it?

A CASE IN POINT: "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening"

"Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" is a very well known poem by Robert Frost. Even so, contemporary readers may be challenged to imagine this kind of scene today. Does that mean the poem is no longer significant? You can decide for yourself after reading it. Before you decide, though, consider how you can pursue meaning on several levels -- by reading for an appreciation of its sound and sense, your own personal reflection, or for a more formal exploration of its meaning through close analysis.

Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening
By Robert Frost

Whose woods these are I think I know.
His house is in the village, though;
He will not see me stopping here
To watch his woods fill up with snow.

My little horse must think it queer
To stop without a farmhouse near
Between the woods and frozen lake
The darkest evening of the year.

He gives his harness bells a shake
To ask if there is some mistake.
The only other sound's the sweep
Of easy wind and downy flake.

The woods are lovely, dark, and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.

Sound and Sense
There's a regular rhythm (iambic tetrameter) and rhyme (aaba, bbcb, ccdc, dddd), which may have a different effect on various readers. Some might find the sound to be soothing, others might find it annoyingly simplistic or sing-songy. But either way, the rhythm and the rhyme give the poem a solid structure: each stanza has the same basic rhythm and the rhyme scheme interlocks the stanzas together. The last verse is the most intense, as all four lines rhyme instead of the usual three, and the last line is a repitition. In the first stanza, the situation is established; a man is passing through the countryside and stops on his way home to admire the beauty of fresh fallen snow on the surrounding forest. In the second stanza, the speaker projects himself into the mind of his horse, conjecturing about his horse's practical concerns. The speaker imagines that his horse thinks it's "queer" they'd be stopping just to stand in the woods for a quiet moment, and in imagining this he seems to be attributing to him the rudimentary power of reason, a practicality he seems keenly aware he himself is not exhibiting. How weird, he imagines his horse (that practical side of himself?) thinking, that we're stopping in the middle of the woods, with no shelter and no food in sight while it's so dark out. Horses are usually more than eager to get back to the barn, and in the third stanza the horse communicates by shaking his harness; you can feel him tossing his head impatiently, trying to spur the homeward journey forward. It's a very realistic scene. And the quiet of the surrounding countryside is further enhanced by the singleness of this little sound. The wind tossing the snowflakes is the only other movement, the only other sound. That extreme quiet and stillness is emphasized. Is it a peaceful stillness, a soft silence? Words like "easy" and "downy" have comforting feel to them. And in the fourth stanza, the speaker tells us straight out that the woods are "lovely, dark, and deep." He'd like to stay and drink in their loveliness, but he decides to continue home. He has responsibilities to attend to--promises to keep. He's got "miles to go" before he can enter into that rest, that peace; he's got miles to go before he can truly sleep.

Analysis
In the first stanza, we see that the speaker is familiar with the land; he knows who owns it…he even seems to wink a bit when he mentions this someone who "owns" the woods, implying that the whole idea of "ownership" may be a little absurd; after all the man doesn't even live on this land that he owns -- he lives in the village. The speaker implies that he's trespassing but since the owner isn't there he can't get in trouble. It's not an ethical problem for him. He feels no guilt about trespassing. Instead, he's seizing the moment, taking advantage of his unexpected freedom and privacy to stop and admire the woods without being noticed or watched. He seems to really appreciate this gift of … a moment. After all, if the owner were there, he wouldn't be able to stop.

So we see him stopping, but we don't know why yet. Maybe he doesn't know himself, yet. Maybe he's a little ambivalent about the scene. Something about it calls to him and he finds himself stopping, vibrating and resonating to the beauty of it, not asking for meaning, but unconsciously open to it if some kind of message reveals itself. On a symbolic or subconscious level, the snow strongly reminds us that the poem is set in winter, which is widely known to be an archetypal image of death. Yet the image of the snow is wrapped in comforting language which gives this wintery, deathly scene a palpable allure. There's a positive tinge to what might otherwise seem bleak.

In the second stanza, we can see how this man is wholly at one and in tune with his surroundings, including his horse. That he wonders what his horse is "thinking" shows his interest in projecting his thoughts imaginatively outside himself, into nature, and he takes a certain pleasure seeing the scene from what he imagines to be his horse's perspective. His horse is the practical one, he muses, while he sits here dreaming, watching the snow fill up the woods, blanketing them in a peaceful, restful sleep, their snowy grave. He just stands there dreaming, and thinking about his horse's feelings is the one thing that brings him back to reality. Death comes calling again in the archetypal image of night, as we're told this is the "darkest evening of the year." It's the winter solstice, getting close to Christmas, which may be a significant, telling detail for some people. There's a lot of depression around Christmas time.

In the third stanza, our speaker is brought back to reality, barely. He's still drawn to the scene, evidenced by the way he notes the quietness of the country after hearing the harness bells shake. The "easy" wind and "downy" flake further extend the suggestion that there's an ease, a softness, a comforting, peaceful, relaxing quality to this death-invested scene (the dark night, the winter, the snow covering the forest like the ground over a grave). Although he's considered the needs of his horse, he can't easily draw himself away from the beauty of the woods. The quietness and the solitude are further symbolic reminders of death. (And perhaps we're talking about a symbolic rather than an actual death -- something psychological or spiritual rather than physical.)

In the fourth stanza, he seems to realize what the attraction has been; he comes forth and admits to himself his attraction to death. What has caused this attraction is ambiguous, however. Maybe his life is hard and death would seem like a welcomed rest from toil. The thought of resting alone on a quiet countryside, buried deep under where no harm can befall, is quite lovely, quite tempting. The promises he refers to are also ambiguous -- are they promises to himself, to his loved ones, to his horse? The resolution is as peaceful as the scene that has unfolded. It seems that this moment has given the man a rare opportunity to reaffirm life; though he's been attracted to death throughout the poem, in the end it is life -- with all of its toils and troubles -- which ultimately wins. And yet the speaker seems to have gained some measure of comfort, some kind of internal reconciliation, for his hard life by recognizing the deep and lovely rest that awaits him once he does die. Instead of being morbid, death becomes a well earned rest for those who have traveled the miles, met their obligations well. On the symbolic level, the speaker now rejects death in favor of meeting his earthly responsibilities. He wants to earn his sleep--he wants to reach death having lived a full life.


 

 

 

     

 


Questions? Contact me.

All materials unless otherwise indicated are copyright © 2001-2002 by Stacy Tartar Esch.
FALL 2001 site is available at BRAINSTORM-SERVICES.COM
The original contents of this site may not be reproduced, republished, reused, or retransmitted
without the express written consent of Stacy Tartar Esch.
These contents are for educational purposes only.